Department of Geography, Ghent University, Krijgslaan 281, S8, B-9000 Ghent, Belgium.
Int J Health Geogr. 2012 Oct 10;11:43. doi: 10.1186/1476-072X-11-43.
Doing regular physical activity has positive effects on health. Several environmental factors are identified as important correlates of physical activity. However, there seems to be a difference between perceived and objective measures of the environment. This study examines the influence of physical activity, neighbourhood walkability, and socio-demographic characteristics on the correspondence between self-reported and objectively measured walking time to urban destinations of adults in the city of Ghent (Belgium).
Previously collected survey data was used from 1164 respondents in the city of Ghent who reported walking times to various closest destinations in the neighbourhood of residence. These were compared with corresponding walking times that were objectively measured through geographical information systems. Physical activity was recorded over a 7-day period using accelerometers. Neighbourhood walkability was assessed on the basis of residential density, connectivity, and land-use mix.
We observed a relatively poor agreement between objective and perceived walking times. Stronger agreements were noted amongst the most physically active group, while low-level walkers tended to overestimate walking time. Surprisingly, however, people residing in a low-walkable neighbourhood underestimated walking times more frequently relative to those in high-walkable neighbourhoods.
Researchers investigating the influence of environmental attributes on physical activity behavior should thus be cautious when using only self-reported environmental data, since these are a priori influenced by physical activity levels and various socio-demographic factors.
定期进行身体活动对健康有积极影响。有几个环境因素被确定为身体活动的重要相关因素。然而,感知到的环境和客观测量的环境之间似乎存在差异。本研究考察了身体活动、邻里可达性和社会人口特征对根特市(比利时)成年人自我报告和客观测量的到达城市目的地步行时间之间一致性的影响。
使用根特市 1164 名受访者的先前收集的调查数据,这些受访者报告了居住在邻里内到各种最近目的地的步行时间。这些与通过地理信息系统客观测量的相应步行时间进行了比较。使用加速度计记录了 7 天的身体活动情况。基于居住密度、连通性和土地利用混合度来评估邻里可达性。
我们观察到客观和感知的步行时间之间存在相对较差的一致性。在最活跃的群体中,一致性更强,而低水平的步行者往往会高估步行时间。然而,令人惊讶的是,与高可达性社区相比,居住在低可达性社区的人更频繁地低估步行时间。
因此,研究环境属性对身体活动行为影响的研究人员在使用仅自我报告的环境数据时应谨慎,因为这些数据预先受到身体活动水平和各种社会人口因素的影响。