Daniels Felicity M, Khanyile Thembisile D
School of Nursing, University of the Western Cape, South Africa.
Nurse Educ Today. 2013 Sep;33(9):956-61. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2012.11.004. Epub 2012 Nov 27.
A fundamental purpose of mergers between higher education institutions (HEIs) in 2002 was to enable sharing of scarce resources between more advanced universities and those historically disadvantaged by the apartheid system of the South African Government. A common teaching platform for undergraduate nursing education in the Western Cape was established in 2005, in line with the transformation of the higher education system, as a collaborative initiative between three universities. In order to evaluate the common teaching platform, Stuffelbeam's context, input, process, product (CIPP) research model was employed. A sample of 108 participants was selected through stratified purposive sampling, and included three deputy vice-chancellors, three deans, three heads of department, 18 lecturers and 81 students. Semi-structured interviews were held with the staff members, whilst the students participated in focus group interviews. Open-ended questions informed by literature and the CIPP evaluation model were developed and used to guide the interviews. This enabled the researcher to obtain a rich description of the participants' experiences. The data were analysed inductively. The results revealed that the main purpose of collaboration was not achieved due to the lack of a common understanding of the concept of collaboration and its purpose; a lack of readiness to collaborate and a lack of sharing of resources. A framework for effective collaboration was developed based on the results.
2002年高等教育机构(HEIs)合并的一个基本目的是使资源更丰富的大学与那些历史上受南非政府种族隔离制度不利影响的大学之间能够共享稀缺资源。2005年,作为三所大学之间的一项合作举措,在西开普建立了一个本科护理教育的通用教学平台,以顺应高等教育系统的转型。为了评估这个通用教学平台,采用了斯塔弗尔比姆的背景、投入、过程、产品(CIPP)研究模型。通过分层目的抽样选取了108名参与者作为样本,包括三名副校长、三名院长、三个系主任、18名讲师和81名学生。对工作人员进行了半结构化访谈,而学生则参与了焦点小组访谈。根据文献和CIPP评估模型设计了开放式问题,并用于指导访谈。这使研究人员能够对参与者的经历进行丰富的描述。对数据进行了归纳分析。结果显示,由于对合作概念及其目的缺乏共同理解、缺乏合作意愿以及缺乏资源共享,合作的主要目的未能实现。基于这些结果制定了一个有效合作的框架。