Department of Population Medicine, University of Guelph, Guelph, ON, Canada.
BMC Public Health. 2013 Jan 22;13:63. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-13-63.
Enteric pathogens are an important cause of illness, however, little is known about their community-level risk factors (e.g., socioeconomic, cultural and physical environmental conditions) in the Northwest Territories (NWT) of Canada. The objective of this study was to undertake ecological (group-level) analyses by combining two existing data sources to examine potential community-level risk factors for campylobacteriosis, giardiasis and salmonellosis, which are three notifiable (mandatory reporting to public health authorities at the time of diagnosis) enteric infections.
The rate of campylobacteriosis was modeled using a Poisson distribution while rates of giardiasis and salmonellosis were modeled using a Negative Binomial distribution. Rate ratios (the ratio of the incidence of disease in the exposed group to the incidence of disease in the non-exposed group) were estimated for infections by the three major pathogens with potential community-level risk factors.
Significant (p≤0.05) associations varied by etiology. There was increased risk of infection with Salmonella for communities with higher proportions of 'households in core need' (unsuitable, inadequate, and/or unaffordable housing) up to 42% after which the rate started to decrease with increasing core need. The risk of giardiasis was significantly higher both with increased 'internal mobility' (population moving between communities), and also where the community's primary health facility was a health center rather than a full-service hospital. Communities with higher health expenditures had a significantly decreased risk of giardiasis. Results of modeling that focused on each of Giardia and Salmonella infections separately supported and expanded upon previous research outcomes that suggested health disparities are often associated with socioeconomic status, geographical and social mobility, as well as access to health care (e.g. facilities, services and professionals). In the campylobacteriosis model, a negative association was found between food prices in communities and risk of infection. There was also a significant interaction between trapping and consumption of traditional foods in communities. Higher rates of community participation in both activities appeared to have a protective effect against campylobacteriosis.
These results raise very interesting questions about the role that traditional activities might play in infectious enteric disease incidence in the NWT, but should be interpreted with caution, recognizing database limitations in collection of case data and risk factor information (e.g. missing data). Given the cultural, socioeconomic, and nutritional benefits associated with traditional food practices, targeted community-based collaborative research is necessary to more fully investigate the statistical correlations identified in this exploratory research. This study demonstrates the value of examining the role of social determinants in the transmission and risk of infectious diseases.
肠道病原体是疾病的一个重要原因,然而,在加拿大西北地区(NWT),人们对其社区层面的风险因素(如社会经济、文化和物理环境条件)知之甚少。本研究的目的是通过结合两个现有数据源进行生态(群体水平)分析,以检验弯曲菌病、贾第虫病和沙门氏菌病的潜在社区层面风险因素,这些都是三种需报告(在诊断时向公共卫生当局强制报告)的肠道感染。
采用泊松分布模型来模拟弯曲菌病的发病率,而贾第虫病和沙门氏菌病的发病率则采用负二项分布模型来模拟。采用比率比(暴露组的疾病发病率与非暴露组的疾病发病率之比)来估计三种主要病原体的感染与潜在的社区水平风险因素的关系。
有统计学意义(p≤0.05)的关联因病因而异。对于“核心需求家庭”(不适合、不足和/或负担不起住房)比例较高的社区,感染沙门氏菌的风险增加,最高可达 42%,之后随着核心需求的增加,发病率开始下降。内部流动性(人口在社区之间流动)增加,以及社区的主要医疗设施是医疗中心而不是全服务医院,都会显著增加贾第虫病的风险。卫生支出较高的社区感染贾第虫病的风险显著降低。针对贾第虫和沙门氏菌感染分别进行的建模结果支持并扩展了先前的研究结果,表明健康差距通常与社会经济地位、地理和社会流动性以及获得医疗保健(例如设施、服务和专业人员)有关。在弯曲菌病模型中,发现社区食品价格与感染风险之间存在负相关关系。社区中传统食物的捕获和消费之间也存在显著的相互作用。社区参与这两种活动的比例较高,似乎对弯曲菌病有保护作用。
这些结果提出了一个非常有趣的问题,即传统活动在 NWT 的传染性肠道疾病发病率中可能扮演的角色,但应谨慎解释,认识到病例数据和风险因素信息收集方面的数据库局限性(例如缺失数据)。考虑到传统食品实践带来的文化、社会经济和营养益处,有必要开展以社区为基础的合作研究,以更充分地调查这一探索性研究中确定的统计相关性。本研究表明,检查社会决定因素在传染病传播和风险中的作用具有价值。