Griffith University, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
Sex Abuse. 2013 Jun;25(3):302-16. doi: 10.1177/1079063212472937. Epub 2013 Feb 6.
Actuarial risk assessment (Static-99 and Static-99-R) scores were obtained for 399 Australian adult sexual offenders who were subsequently released from prison and followed up with searches of police arrest records (mean follow-up period = 29 months; range = 15-53 months). Indigenous offenders (n = 67; 16.8%) scored significantly higher on both the Static-99 (M = 4.04 vs. 2.89, p < .001) and Static-99-R (M = 3.72 vs. 2.22, p < .001), were more than twice as likely to be arrested for sexual offenses (9.0% vs. 4.1%, ns), and were significantly more likely to be arrested for nonsexual violent (28.4% vs. 1.9%, p < .001), any violent (including sexual; 37% vs. 5.9%, p < .001), and any offenses (58.2% vs. 21.6%, p < .001). For the combined groups, predictive accuracy of both instruments was comparable to results reported elsewhere. Predictive accuracy of the Static-99 was similar for indigenous and nonindigenous offenders. The Static-99-R was only marginally predictive of any violent recidivism (AUC = .65, 95% CI = [.52, .79]), and did not predict sexual (AUC = .61, 95% CI = [.45, .77]) or nonsexual violent recidivism (AUC = .65, 95% CI = [.48, .78]), for indigenous offenders. Higher risk scores, indigenous race, and unsupervised release all contributed unique variance to any violent recidivism. Results suggest that the Static-99 may be appropriate for assessing Australian indigenous sexual offenders, but more research is needed to test the validity of the Static-99-R for this population. We conclude that practitioners should consider the potential effects of racial differences and postrelease factors, as well as static risk factors, in their assessments.
对 399 名澳大利亚成年性犯罪者进行了精算风险评估(静态-99 和静态-99-R)评分,随后对他们进行了警方逮捕记录的搜索(平均随访期=29 个月;范围=15-53 个月)。土著犯罪者(n=67;16.8%)在静态-99(M=4.04 与 2.89,p<.001)和静态-99-R(M=3.72 与 2.22,p<.001)上的得分显著更高,被捕的性犯罪的可能性是后者的两倍多(9.0%对 4.1%,无显著差异),被捕的非性暴力犯罪(28.4%对 1.9%,p<.001)、任何暴力犯罪(包括性犯罪;37%对 5.9%,p<.001)和任何犯罪(58.2%对 21.6%,p<.001)的可能性都显著更高。对于联合组,两种工具的预测准确性与其他地方报告的结果相当。静态-99 对土著和非土著犯罪者的预测准确性相似。静态-99-R 对任何暴力累犯的预测能力仅略高(AUC=.65,95%CI=[.52,.79]),并且不能预测性暴力(AUC=.61,95%CI=[.45,.77])或非性暴力累犯(AUC=.65,95%CI=[.48,.78]),对于土著犯罪者。更高的风险评分、土著种族和无监督释放都对任何暴力累犯有独特的贡献。结果表明,静态-99 可能适用于评估澳大利亚土著性犯罪者,但需要进一步研究来检验静态-99-R 对这一人群的有效性。我们得出的结论是,从业者在评估时应考虑种族差异和释放后因素以及静态风险因素的潜在影响。