Mobasher Mina, Nakhaee Nouzar, Tahmasebi Mamak, Zahedi Farzaneh, Larijani Bagher
Faculty of Medicine, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran ; Medical Ethics and History of Medicine Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Iran J Public Health. 2013;42(2):188-96. Epub 2013 Feb 1.
In the recent years, advances in medical technologies for end stage cancer patients' care have affected the end-of-life decision-making in clinical practice and exposed oncologists to serious ethical dilemmas. But little is known about oncologists' viewpoints in our country regarding their ethical problems in this mention. We aimed to clarify the ethical dilemmas which Iranian oncologists may face in our health care setting and to determine factors influencing decision-making process.
In this qualitative study, a phenomenological approach was used. We interviewed 8 cancer specialists in teaching hospitals in Iran and used content analysis to identify codes and categorize themes in the data.
DURING THE PROCESS OF ANALYSIS, THREE MAIN THEMES EMERGED ABOUT ETHICAL DILEMMAS IN END OF LIFE CARE FOR ADVANCED CANCER PATIENTS: illness factors, socio-cultural context and patient-physician relationship. Cancer specialists identified ethical problems on several main issues, the most important of which were telling the truth in Iranian cultural context, uncertainty in end stage definition, multidisciplinary team working and cost consideration in Iranian health care system.
Health care and insurance system in Iran face to end of life care challenges; therefore, health care providers and policy makers need to allocate appropriate resources and programs to improve quality of care in terminal stages. Appropriate physicians' communication skills training, multidisciplinary team working and supplementary insurance services that provide essential health care can improve the quality of care of patients with end stages of cancer. The findings of this study can help us to provide ethical policies for decision-making in end-of-life care.
近年来,终末期癌症患者护理的医学技术进步影响了临床实践中的临终决策,并使肿瘤学家面临严重的伦理困境。但在我国,对于肿瘤学家在这方面伦理问题的观点知之甚少。我们旨在阐明伊朗肿瘤学家在我们的医疗环境中可能面临的伦理困境,并确定影响决策过程的因素。
在这项定性研究中,采用了现象学方法。我们采访了伊朗教学医院的8位癌症专家,并使用内容分析法来识别数据中的编码并对主题进行分类。
在分析过程中,出现了关于晚期癌症患者临终护理伦理困境的三个主要主题:疾病因素、社会文化背景和医患关系。癌症专家在几个主要问题上确定了伦理问题,其中最重要的是伊朗文化背景下的告知真相、终末期定义的不确定性、多学科团队合作以及伊朗医疗保健系统中的成本考虑。
伊朗的医疗保健和保险系统面临临终护理挑战;因此,医疗保健提供者和政策制定者需要分配适当的资源和项目,以提高末期护理质量。适当的医生沟通技能培训、多学科团队合作以及提供基本医疗保健的补充保险服务可以提高癌症末期患者的护理质量。本研究结果有助于我们为临终护理决策提供伦理政策。