Betz Marian E, Schwartz Robert, Valley Morgan, Lowenstein Steven R
School of Medicine, University of Colorado, Denver, USA.
J Prim Care Community Health. 2012 Jul 1;3(3):150-4. doi: 10.1177/2150131911423276. Epub 2012 Jan 6.
To describe older adults' opinions about driving cessation and driver retesting.
Older adult (≥ 65 years) patients visiting the emergency department or geriatric clinic at a university hospital completed a confidential survey regarding attitudes toward driving tests and restrictions.
The response rate was 50% (N = 169). The median age was 75 years (range, 65-98); 53% were women. Most reported driving at least occasionally (78%; 95% confidence interval [95% CI], 72-84). Twelve percent (95% CI, 7-18) reported a crash in the prior year; most (84%; 95% CI, 78-90) reported at least 1 medical diagnosis possibly linked to increased crash risk. Most participants (74%; 95% CI, 67-81) supported mandatory, age-based driver retesting but thought family (73%; 95% CI, 68-81) or physicians (60%; 95% CI, 54-69) should determine license revocation for an unsafe driver rather than the Department of Motor Vehicles (34%; 95% CI, 28-42) or the police (30%; 95% CI, 23-37). Almost all reported they would consider driving cessation if recommended by a physician (88%; 95% CI, 82-94) or family member (71%; 95% CI, 63-79), without significant age or sex differences.
Older drivers support mandatory age-based testing but appear more likely to follow recommendations from physicians or family members, thereby supporting a role for physician counseling, driver evaluations, and advanced driving directives.
描述老年人对停止驾驶和重新进行驾驶测试的看法。
在大学医院急诊科或老年诊所就诊的老年(≥65岁)患者完成了一项关于对驾驶测试和限制态度的保密调查。
回复率为50%(N = 169)。中位年龄为75岁(范围65 - 98岁);53%为女性。大多数人报告至少偶尔开车(78%;95%置信区间[95%CI],72 - 84)。12%(95%CI,7 - 18)报告上一年发生过撞车事故;大多数人(84%;95%CI,78 - 90)报告至少有一种可能与撞车风险增加相关的医学诊断。大多数参与者(74%;95%CI,67 - 81)支持基于年龄的强制性重新驾驶测试,但认为应由家人(73%;95%CI,68 - 81)或医生(60%;95%CI,54 - 69)决定吊销不安全驾驶员的驾照,而不是机动车管理部门(34%;95%CI,28 - 42)或警方(30%;95%CI,23 - 37)。几乎所有人都报告说,如果医生(88%;95%CI,82 - 94)或家庭成员(71%;95%CI,63 - 79)建议,他们会考虑停止驾驶,且无显著年龄或性别差异。
老年驾驶员支持基于年龄的强制性测试,但似乎更有可能听从医生或家庭成员的建议,从而支持医生咨询、驾驶员评估和高级驾驶指令的作用。