Department of Policy Analysis and Management and Cornell Population Center, Cornell University, United States.
Soc Sci Res. 2013 Nov;42(6):1712-25. doi: 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2013.07.011. Epub 2013 Jul 19.
Extensive research has documented the challenges that undocumented immigrants face in navigating U.S. labor markets, but relatively little has explored the impact of legal status on residential outcomes despite their widespread repercussions for social well-being. Using data from the 1996-2008 panels of the Survey of Income and Program Participation to impute documentation status among Mexican and Central American immigrants, we examine group differences in residential outcomes, including homeownership, housing crowding, satisfaction with neighborhood and housing quality, problems with neighborhood crime/safety, governmental services, and environmental issues, and deficiencies with housing units. Results from our analysis indicate that undocumented householders are far less likely to be homeowners than documented migrants, and also live in more crowded homes, report greater structural deficiencies with their dwellings, and express greater concern about the quality of public services and environmental conditions in their neighborhoods. In comparison to native whites, undocumented migrants' residential circumstances are lacking, but their residential outcomes tend to be superior to those of native-born blacks. Overall, our results highlight the pervasive impact of legal status on stratifying Mexicans' and Central Americans' prospects for successful incorporation, but also underscore the rigidity of the black/nonblack divide structuring American residential contexts.
大量研究记录了无证移民在美国劳动力市场中所面临的挑战,但相对较少的研究探讨了法律地位对居住结果的影响,尽管这些影响对社会福祉有着广泛的影响。利用收入和计划参与调查 1996-2008 年期间的面板数据,我们推断了墨西哥和中美洲移民的文件身份,研究了居住结果方面的群体差异,包括住房拥有率、住房拥挤程度、对邻里和住房质量的满意度、邻里犯罪/安全问题、政府服务和环境问题以及住房单位的缺陷。我们的分析结果表明,无证住户成为房主的可能性远远低于有证件的移民,而且他们居住的房屋更加拥挤,报告的住房结构性缺陷更多,对邻里公共服务和环境条件的质量表示更大的担忧。与本土白人相比,无证移民的居住环境较差,但他们的居住结果往往优于本土出生的黑人。总的来说,我们的结果强调了法律地位对墨西哥人和中美洲人成功融入社会的前景产生深远影响,但也突显了构成美国居住环境的黑人和非黑人之间的僵化划分。