Shannon Geordan D, Alberg Corinna, Nacul Luis, Pashayan Nora
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, Institute of Public Health, University Forvie Site, University of Cambridge, Robinson Way, Cambridge, CB2 2SR, UK,
Matern Child Health J. 2014 Aug;18(6):1354-79. doi: 10.1007/s10995-013-1370-2.
Congenital disorders are a leading cause of global burden of disease; the birth prevalence remains constant at 6%. Initiating preconception care before pregnancy may be an effective strategy to reduce congenital disorders and improve the health of reproductive-age women. Our objectives are: (1) To identify components of preconception interventions, (2) to assess the effectiveness of preconception interventions in reducing the burden of congenital disorders, and (3) to prioritize these interventions. Medline and Science Direct search terms included: preconception, pre-pregnancy, childbearing, reproduction, care, intervention, primary care, healthcare, model, program, prevention, trial, efficacy, effectiveness, congenital disorders OR abnormalities. Inclusion criteria were: (1) English, (2) human subjects, (3) women of childbearing age, (4) 1980-current data, (5) all countries, (6) experimental studies, (7) systematic reviews or meta-analysis, (8) program reports/evaluations. Data was collected and abstracted by two independent reviewers. To prioritize preconception interventions likely to have the largest impact at a population level, a ranked scoring system was created incorporating the following: (1) quality of evidence supporting the intervention, (2) effect size of the intervention, and (3) global burden of the specific congenital disease. Preconception interventions include risk screening, education, motivational counseling, disease optimization and specialist referral. The most effective interventions, based on the strength of evidence, size of impact of intervention, and disease burden are: folic acid fortification/supplementation, diabetic control, smoking and alcohol interventions, HIV management, thrombophillia screening, obesity prevention and epilepsy management. Although multiple conditions require preconception attention, only nine interventions have evidence to support their effect on congenital disorders through a randomised control trial, systematic review or meta-analysis. There is a need for more high-level research in evaluating certain preconception interventions. These findings have significant implications on planning and implementation of preconception care.
先天性疾病是全球疾病负担的主要原因之一;出生患病率一直保持在6%。在怀孕前开始进行孕前保健可能是减少先天性疾病和改善育龄妇女健康的有效策略。我们的目标是:(1)确定孕前干预的组成部分;(2)评估孕前干预在减轻先天性疾病负担方面的有效性;(3)对这些干预措施进行优先排序。Medline和Science Direct的检索词包括:孕前、怀孕前、生育、生殖、保健、干预、初级保健、医疗保健、模式、项目、预防、试验、疗效、有效性、先天性疾病或异常。纳入标准为:(1)英文;(2)人体研究对象;(3)育龄妇女;(4)1980年至今的数据;(5)所有国家;(6)实验研究;(7)系统评价或荟萃分析;(8)项目报告/评估。数据由两名独立的评审员收集和提取。为了对可能在人群层面产生最大影响的孕前干预措施进行优先排序,创建了一个排名评分系统,该系统纳入了以下内容:(1)支持该干预措施的证据质量;(2)干预措施的效应大小;(3)特定先天性疾病的全球负担。孕前干预包括风险筛查、教育、动机咨询、疾病优化和专科转诊。根据证据强度、干预影响大小和疾病负担,最有效的干预措施是:叶酸强化/补充、糖尿病控制、吸烟和饮酒干预、艾滋病毒管理、血栓形成倾向筛查、肥胖预防和癫痫管理。尽管多种情况需要孕前关注,但只有九种干预措施有证据通过随机对照试验、系统评价或荟萃分析来支持其对先天性疾病的影响。需要更多高水平的研究来评估某些孕前干预措施。这些发现对孕前保健的规划和实施具有重要意义。