Ambrose Adrian Jacques H, Lin Susan Y, Chun Maria B J
J Grad Med Educ. 2013 Jun;5(2):227-31. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-12-00085.1.
Cultural competency is an important skill that prepares physicians to care for patients from diverse backgrounds.
We reviewed Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) program requirements and relevant documents from the ACGME website to evaluate competency requirements across specialties.
The program requirements for each specialty and its subspecialties were reviewed from December 2011 through February 2012. The review focused on the 3 competency domains relevant to culturally competent care: professionalism, interpersonal and communication skills, and patient care. Specialty and subspecialty requirements were assigned a score between 0 and 3 (from least specific to most specific). Given the lack of a standardized cultural competence rating system, the scoring was based on explicit mention of specific keywords.
A majority of program requirements fell into the low- or no-specificity score (1 or 0). This included 21 core specialties (leading to primary board certification) program requirements (78%) and 101 subspecialty program requirements (79%). For all specialties, cultural competency elements did not gravitate toward any particular competency domain. Four of 5 primary care program requirements (pediatrics, obstetrics-gynecology, family medicine, and psychiatry) acquired the high-specificity score of 3, in comparison to only 1 of 22 specialty care program requirements (physical medicine and rehabilitation).
The degree of specificity, as judged by use of keywords in 3 competency domains, in ACGME requirements regarding cultural competency is highly variable across specialties and subspecialties. Greater specificity in requirements is expected to benefit the acquisition of cultural competency in residents, but this has not been empirically tested.
文化能力是一项重要技能,能让医生为来自不同背景的患者提供护理。
我们查阅了研究生医学教育认证委员会(ACGME)的项目要求以及ACGME网站上的相关文件,以评估各专业的能力要求。
2011年12月至2012年2月期间,对每个专业及其亚专业的项目要求进行了审查。审查重点关注与文化胜任力护理相关的3个能力领域:专业精神、人际沟通技能和患者护理。专业和亚专业要求被赋予0至3分(从最不具体到最具体)。由于缺乏标准化的文化能力评级系统,评分基于对特定关键词的明确提及。
大多数项目要求属于低特异性或无特异性评分(1或0)。这包括21个核心专业(通向初级委员会认证)的项目要求(78%)和101个亚专业项目要求(79%)。对于所有专业,文化能力要素并未倾向于任何特定的能力领域。5个初级保健项目要求(儿科学、妇产科学、家庭医学和精神病学)中有4个获得了3分的高特异性评分,相比之下,22个专科护理项目要求(物理医学与康复)中只有1个获得该评分。
根据3个能力领域中关键词的使用判断,ACGME关于文化能力的要求在各专业和亚专业之间的特异性程度差异很大。要求具有更高的特异性有望有助于住院医师获得文化能力,但这尚未经过实证检验。