Applied Research Associates, Panama City, FL.
Applied Research Associates, Panama City, FL.
Am J Infect Control. 2014 Mar;42(3):265-70. doi: 10.1016/j.ajic.2013.09.014. Epub 2014 Jan 23.
Decontamination, cleaning, and reuse of filtering facepiece respirators (FFRs) has been proposed to mitigate an acute FFR shortage during a public health emergency. Our study evaluates the ability of commercially available wipe products to clean FFRs contaminated with either infectious or noninfectious aerosols.
Three models of surgical N95 FFRs were contaminated with aerosols of mucin or viable Staphylococcus aureus then cleaned with hypochlorite, benzalkonium chloride, or nonantimicrobial wipes. After cleaning, FFRs were separated into components (nose pad, fabrics, and perforated strip), and contaminants were extracted and quantified. Filtration performance was assessed for cleaned FFRs.
Mucin removal was <1 log for all wipe products on all components. Inert wipes achieved ∼1-log attenuation in viable S aureus on fabrics from all FFR models--removal was less effective from nose pads and perforated edges. Both antimicrobial wipes achieved 3-5-log attenuation on most components, with smaller reductions on nose pads and greater reductions on perforated strips. Particle penetration following cleaning yielded mean values <5%. The highest penetrations were observed in FFRs cleaned with benzalkonium chloride wipes.
FFRs can be disinfected using antimicrobial wipe products, but not effectively cleaned with the wipes evaluated in this study. This study provides informative data for the development of better FFRs and applicable cleaning products.
为缓解公共卫生紧急事件期间过滤式面罩呼吸器(FFR)的严重短缺问题,人们提出对其进行消毒、清洁和重复使用。本研究评估了市售擦拭产品清洁受传染性或非传染性气溶胶污染的 FFR 的能力。
将三种型号的外科用 N95 FFR 用粘蛋白或有活力的金黄色葡萄球菌气溶胶污染,然后用次氯酸盐、苯扎氯铵或非抗菌擦拭布进行清洁。清洁后,FFR 被拆分为各组成部分(鼻垫、织物和穿孔带),并提取和定量污染物。对清洁后的 FFR 进行过滤性能评估。
对于所有组件,所有擦拭产品对粘蛋白的去除率均<1 对数。惰性擦拭布可使所有 FFR 模型织物上的有活力金黄色葡萄球菌衰减约 1 对数,而从鼻垫和穿孔边缘的去除效果较差。两种抗菌擦拭布对大多数组件的去除率均达到 3-5 对数,而对鼻垫的去除效果较小,对穿孔带的去除效果较大。清洁后的颗粒物穿透率平均值<5%。在使用苯扎氯铵擦拭布清洁的 FFR 中观察到最高的穿透率。
可以使用抗菌擦拭产品对 FFR 进行消毒,但用本研究中评估的擦拭布无法有效清洁。本研究为开发更好的 FFR 和适用的清洁产品提供了有价值的数据。