Pediatric Intensive Care - Instituto da Criança do Hospital das Clínicas da Faculdade de Medicina, São Paulo University, Rua do Carreiro de Pedra 111 apto 152C, Jd, Caravelas, CEP 04728-020 São Paulo, Brazil.
BMC Med Educ. 2014 Feb 5;14:25. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-14-25.
Focused echocardiographic examinations performed by intensivists and emergency room physicians can be a valuable tool for diagnosing and managing the hemodynamic status of critically ill children. The aim of this study was to evaluate the learning curve achieved using a theoretical and practical training program designed to enable pediatric intensivists and emergency physicians to conduct targeted echocardiograms.
Theoretical and practical training sessions were conducted with 16 pediatric intensivist/emergency room physicians. The program included qualitative analyses of the left ventricular (LV) and right ventricular (RV) functions, evaluation of pericardial effusion/cardiac tamponade and valvular regurgitation and measurements of the distensibility index of the inferior vena cava (dIVC), ejection fraction (EF) and cardiac index (CI). The practical training sessions were conducted in the intensive care unit; each student performed 24 echocardiograms. The students in training were evaluated in a practical manner, and the results were compared with the corresponding examinations performed by experienced echocardiographers. The evaluations occurred after 8, 16 and 24 practical examinations.
The concordance rates between the students and echocardiographers in the subjective analysis of the LV function were 81.3% at the first evaluation, 96.9% at the second evaluation and 100% at the third evaluation (p < 0.001). For the dIVC, we observed a concordance of 46.7% at the first evaluation, 90.3% at the second evaluation and 87.5% at the third evaluation (p = 0.004). The means of the differences between the students' and echocardiographers' measurements of the EF and CI were 7% and 0.56 L/min/m2, respectively, after the third stage of training.
The proposed training was demonstrated to be sufficient for enabling pediatric physicians to analyze subjective LV function and to measure dIVC, EF and CI. This training course should facilitate the design of other echocardiography training courses that could be implemented in medical residency programs to improve these physicians' technical skills and the care of critically ill patients.
重症监护医师和急诊医师进行的重点超声心动图检查可以成为诊断和管理危重病儿血流动力学状态的有价值的工具。本研究的目的是评估使用理论和实践培训计划使儿科重症监护医师和急诊医师能够进行靶向超声心动图检查的学习曲线。
对 16 名儿科重症监护医师/急诊医师进行了理论和实践培训。该方案包括对左心室(LV)和右心室(RV)功能的定性分析,评估心包积液/心脏压塞和瓣膜反流以及下腔静脉(dIVC)扩张指数、射血分数(EF)和心指数(CI)的测量。实践培训在重症监护病房进行;每位学生进行 24 次超声心动图检查。对受训学生进行了实践评估,并将结果与经验丰富的超声心动图医师进行的相应检查进行了比较。评估在 24 次实践检查后进行。
在 LV 功能的主观分析中,学生与超声心动图医师的一致性率在第一次评估时为 81.3%,第二次评估时为 96.9%,第三次评估时为 100%(p < 0.001)。对于 dIVC,我们观察到第一次评估时的一致性为 46.7%,第二次评估时为 90.3%,第三次评估时为 87.5%(p = 0.004)。在第三阶段培训后,学生和超声心动图医师测量的 EF 和 CI 的差异平均值分别为 7%和 0.56 L/min/m2。
所提出的培训被证明足以使儿科医生能够分析主观的 LV 功能并测量 dIVC、EF 和 CI。该培训课程应有助于设计其他超声心动图培训课程,这些课程可以在医学住院医师培训计划中实施,以提高这些医生的技术技能和危重病患者的护理水平。