Scott Julia K, Leary Sam D, Ness Andy R, Sandy Jonathan R, Persson Martin, Kilpatrick Nicky, Waylen Andrea E
Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 2014 Sep;51(5):e102-9. doi: 10.1597/13-110. Epub 2014 Feb 7.
Objective : To examine current provision of cleft lip and/or palate services in the U.K. and compliance with recommendations made by the Clinical Standards Advisory Group (CSAG) in 1998. Design : Cross-sectional questionnaire survey. Setting : All 11 services within the U.K. providing care for children born with a cleft lip and palate. Participants : Members from each healthcare specialty in each U.K. cleft team. Interventions : Self-administered postal questionnaires enquired about the provision of cleft services. Data were collected about the overall cleft service, team coordination, hearing, orthodontics, pediatric dentistry, primary cleft surgery, psychology, restorative dentistry, secondary surgery, specialist cleft nursing, and speech and language therapy. Results : Questionnaires were returned from members of 130/150 cleft teams (87%) and these showed that U.K. cleft services have been restructured to 11 centralized services with 17 primary operative sites and 61 peripheral sites. All services provide care through a multidisciplinary (MDT) model, but the composition of each team varies. Primary cleft surgery and orthodontics were the only specialties that were represented in all cleft teams. Specialties may be represented in a team but their attendance at MDT clinics is variable. Only one team met all of the CSAG recommendations. Conclusions : Our survey shows that cleft services have centralized over the last 10 years, and an MDT model of care has been adopted. Further research is needed to show how this has influenced outcomes and to see whether some models of centralized care are associated with better outcomes.
调查英国目前唇腭裂服务的提供情况以及是否符合临床标准咨询小组(CSAG)在1998年提出的建议。设计:横断面问卷调查。背景:英国所有为唇腭裂患儿提供护理的11项服务。参与者:英国每个唇腭裂治疗团队中各医疗专业的成员。干预措施:通过自填式邮政问卷询问唇腭裂服务的提供情况。收集了有关整体唇腭裂服务、团队协作、听力、正畸、儿童牙科、初次唇腭裂手术、心理学、修复牙科、二次手术、专科唇腭裂护理以及言语和语言治疗的数据。结果:150个唇腭裂治疗团队中有130个团队(87%)的成员回复了问卷,结果显示英国的唇腭裂服务已重组为11个集中服务点,有17个主要手术地点和61个周边地点。所有服务均通过多学科(MDT)模式提供护理,但每个团队的组成各不相同。初次唇腭裂手术和正畸是所有唇腭裂治疗团队中都有的唯一专业。各专业可能在团队中有代表,但他们参加多学科门诊的情况各不相同。只有一个团队符合CSAG的所有建议。结论:我们的调查表明,在过去10年中唇腭裂服务已实现集中化,并采用了多学科护理模式。需要进一步研究以表明这对治疗结果有何影响,以及是否某些集中护理模式与更好的治疗结果相关。