Department of Operative Dentistry, School of Dentistry, University of North Carolina, 5405H Kory Oral Health Sciences Building, CB#7455, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7455;.
J Dent Educ. 2014 Mar;78(3):401-10.
In spring 2011, a study was initiated to investigate the nature and extent of gender issues in clinical dental education at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Dentistry. Surveys were sent to 236 dental students in the second, third, and fourth years; eighty-six (36.4 percent) responded. Surveys were also sent to seventy-one full-time dental faculty members who had clinical contact with students, and thirty-four (47.9 percent) responded. Of the student respondents, fifty-one were female and thirty-five were male; the faculty respondents were ten women and twenty-four men. A significantly greater proportion of female than male student respondents reported that issues related to gender affected clinical training. The female students also responded that mentorship was less available and less in content for them compared to males, and significantly more female than male students reported lower self-confidence in clinical settings. Among faculty respondents, a higher proportion of women than men reported insufficient awareness of gender issues. These faculty members also reported thinking that female students showed more empathy toward patients than males. Both faculty and student respondents said that female faculty members received less respect from students than did male faculty members. Forty-eight percent of the students reported experiencing or witnessing gender-based prejudice in clinical settings, and 7.0 percent reported experiencing or witnessing unwelcome sexual advances or conduct. A more robust study to include other dental institutions is needed. With confirmation of specific gender issues, corrective measures could be recommended to improve the climate for both females and males in the clinical component of dental education.
2011 年春季,北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校牙科学院启动了一项研究,旨在调查临床牙科学术教育中的性别问题的性质和程度。调查发给了二年级、三年级和四年级的 236 名牙科学生;有 86 人(36.4%)做出了回应。调查还发给了 71 名与学生有临床接触的全职牙科教师,其中 34 人(47.9%)做出了回应。在学生受访者中,有 51 名女性和 35 名男性;教师受访者中,有 10 名女性和 24 名男性。与男性相比,比例显著更高的女性学生报告称,性别相关问题影响了临床培训。女学生还表示,与男性相比,她们获得的指导机会更少、内容也更少,而且在临床环境中,明显更多的女学生报告说自信心较低。在教师受访者中,比例显著更高的女性表示,她们对性别问题的认识不足。这些教师还报告说,他们认为女学生比男学生对患者更有同理心。教师和学生受访者都表示,女教师从学生那里得到的尊重比男教师少。48%的学生报告在临床环境中经历或目睹过基于性别的偏见,7.0%的学生报告经历或目睹过不受欢迎的性侵犯或行为。需要进行一项更具规模的研究,以包括其他牙科机构。如果确认存在具体的性别问题,可以建议采取纠正措施,以改善临床牙科教育中女性和男性的环境。