Peters Anya Bostian
Assistant Professor, University of Massachusetts Lowell, Lowell, MA..
J Prof Nurs. 2014 May-Jun;30(3):213-27. doi: 10.1016/j.profnurs.2013.09.007. Epub 2014 Feb 24.
Academic incivility creates a challenging work environment for nursing faculty. Understanding the concept of faculty-to-faculty incivility may enlighten faculty regarding appropriate interpersonal relationships, assist in alleviating uncivil behavior, and improve the likelihood that faculty will remain in nursing education, potentially easing the current nursing faculty shortage. The primary purpose of this study was to describe novice nurse faculty members' lived experiences of faculty-to-faculty incivility. A second purpose was to describe and understand how incivility influences faculty decision to remain in nursing academia. A hermeneutical phenomenological approach was selected to uncover the lived experience. A purposive sample of eight novice nursing faculty, those with less than 5 years of experience, was obtained via e-mail recruitment from mid-Atlantic college Web sites. Five themes and 7 subthemes emerged. Among the findings were sensing rejection, employing behaviors to cope with uncivil colleagues, sensing others wanted novice faculty to fail, sensing a possessiveness of territory from senior faculty, and struggling with the decision to remain in the faculty position. This study is significant in that understanding of faculty-to-faculty incivility adds insight and an increased sensitivity related to uncivil interactions and may contribute to the design of evidence-based interventions supporting increased collegiality that fosters an environment conducive for the recruitment and retention of faculty.
学术不文明行为为护理教师营造了一个充满挑战的工作环境。理解教师之间不文明行为的概念可能会让教师了解适当的人际关系,有助于减少不文明行为,并提高教师留在护理教育领域的可能性,从而有可能缓解当前护理教师短缺的问题。本研究的主要目的是描述新手护士教师对教师之间不文明行为的亲身经历。第二个目的是描述和理解不文明行为如何影响教师留在护理学术界的决定。本研究采用诠释现象学方法来揭示亲身经历。通过电子邮件从大西洋中部地区学院网站招募了八名新手护理教师(即经验少于5年的教师)作为目的抽样样本。研究得出了五个主题和七个子主题。研究结果包括感受到被排斥、采取行为应对不文明的同事、感觉到其他人希望新手教师失败、感觉到资深教师对领地的占有欲,以及在决定是否继续担任教师职位时挣扎。这项研究具有重要意义,因为对教师之间不文明行为的理解增加了对不文明互动的洞察力和敏感度,并可能有助于设计基于证据的干预措施,以促进更高的同事关系,营造有利于教师招聘和留任的环境。