Shin Hangsik, Cho Jaegeol
Digital Media and Communication Research Center, Samsung Electronics, co, ltd,, Maetan3-dong, Suwon, South Korea.
Biomed Eng Online. 2014 Aug 15;13:116. doi: 10.1186/1475-925X-13-116.
Snoring can be a representative symptom of a sleep disorder, and thus snoring detection is quite important to improving the quality of an individual's daily life. The purpose of this research is to develop an unconstrained snoring detection technique that can be integrated into a smartphone application. In contrast with previous studies, we developed a practical technique for snoring detection during ordinary sleep by using the built-in sound recording system of a smartphone, and the recording was carried out in a standard private bedroom.
The experimental protocol was designed to include a variety of actions that frequently produce noise (including coughing, playing music, talking, rining an alarm, opening/closing doors, running a fan, playing the radio, and walking) in order to accurately recreate the actual circumstances during sleep. The sound data were recorded for 10 individuals during actual sleep. In total, 44 snoring data sets and 75 noise datasets were acquired. The algorithm uses formant analysis to examine sound features according to the frequency and magnitude. Then, a quadratic classifier is used to distinguish snoring from non-snoring noises. Ten-fold cross validation was used to evaluate the developed snoring detection methods, and validation was repeated 100 times randomly to improve statistical effectiveness.
The overall results showed that the proposed method is competitive with those from previous research. The proposed method presented 95.07% accuracy, 98.58% sensitivity, 94.62% specificity, and 70.38% positive predictivity.
Though there was a relatively high false positive rate, the results show the possibility for ubiquitous personal snoring detection through a smartphone application that takes into account data from normally occurring noises without training using preexisting data.
打鼾可能是睡眠障碍的一个典型症状,因此打鼾检测对于提高个人日常生活质量非常重要。本研究的目的是开发一种可集成到智能手机应用程序中的无约束打鼾检测技术。与先前的研究不同,我们利用智能手机的内置录音系统开发了一种在正常睡眠期间进行打鼾检测的实用技术,并且录音是在标准的私人卧室中进行的。
实验方案设计包括各种经常产生噪音的行为(包括咳嗽、播放音乐、交谈、设置闹钟、开门/关门、运行风扇、播放收音机和行走),以便准确重现睡眠期间的实际情况。在实际睡眠期间为10个人记录了声音数据。总共获取了44个打鼾数据集和75个噪声数据集。该算法使用共振峰分析根据频率和幅度检查声音特征。然后,使用二次分类器区分打鼾声和非打鼾噪音。采用十折交叉验证来评估所开发的打鼾检测方法,并随机重复验证100次以提高统计效力。
总体结果表明,所提出的方法与先前研究的方法具有竞争力。所提出的方法呈现出95.07%的准确率、98.58%的灵敏度、94.62%的特异性和70.38%的阳性预测值。
尽管假阳性率相对较高,但结果表明通过智能手机应用程序进行普遍的个人打鼾检测是有可能的,该应用程序考虑了来自正常发生的噪音的数据,无需使用预先存在的数据进行训练。