Encandela John, Gibson Crystal, Angoff Nancy, Leydon Gary, Green Michael
Teaching and Learning Center, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, USA; Department of Psychiatry, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, USA;
Teaching and Learning Center, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, USA.
Med Educ Online. 2014 Aug 13;19:25211. doi: 10.3402/meo.v19.25211. eCollection 2014.
Medical students may experience test anxiety associated with 'high stakes' exams, such as Step 1 of the United States Medical Licensing Examination.
We collected qualitative responses about test anxiety at three points in time from 93 second-year medical students engaged in studying for and taking Step 1.
Causes of test anxiety as reported by students were related to negative self-talk during preparation for the exam. Effects of anxiety had to do with emotional well-being, cognitive functioning, and physical well-being. Strategies included socializing with others and a variety of cognitive and physical approaches. Comparison of individuals' strategies with causes and effects showed some congruence, but substantial incongruence between the types of strategies chosen and the reported causes and effects of test anxiety.
Students' adoption of a 'menu' of strategies rather than one or two carefully selected strategies suggest inefficiencies that might be addressed by interventions, such as advisor-directed conversations with students and incorporating student self-assessment and strategies for managing anxiety within courses on test-taking. Such interventions are in need of further study. An annotated list of evidence-based strategies would be helpful to students and educators. Most important, test anxiety should be viewed by medical educators as a 'real' experience, and students would benefit from educator support.
医学生可能会经历与“高风险”考试相关的考试焦虑,比如美国医师执照考试第一步。
我们在三个时间点收集了93名正在备考并参加第一步考试的二年级医学生关于考试焦虑的定性反馈。
学生报告的考试焦虑原因与考试准备期间的消极自我对话有关。焦虑的影响涉及情绪健康、认知功能和身体健康。应对策略包括与他人交往以及各种认知和身体方面的方法。将个人的应对策略与原因及影响进行比较,发现存在一些一致性,但在所选策略类型与报告的考试焦虑原因及影响之间也存在很大的不一致。
学生采用一系列策略而非精心挑选的一两种策略,这表明存在低效情况,可能需要通过一些干预措施来解决,比如与学生进行导师指导的谈话,以及在应试课程中纳入学生自我评估和管理焦虑的策略。此类干预措施需要进一步研究。一份有注释的循证策略清单对学生和教育工作者会有帮助。最重要的是,医学教育工作者应将考试焦虑视为一种“真实”的体验,学生将受益于教育工作者的支持。