Deuschl G, Lücking C H, Schenck E
Neurologische Klinik, Universität Freiburg, Federal Republic of Germany.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1989 Jun;52(6):755-62. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.52.6.755.
Thenar reflexes following electrical stimulation of the median nerve (containing proprioceptive and cutaneous afferents) and the radial superficial nerve (cutaneous afferents only) were investigated in 23 patients with manifest Huntington's disease (HD) at an early stage, in 17 clinically healthy descendants of HD-patients and in 18 patients with choreatic hyperkinesia due to various aetiologies other than HD. In 61% of the patients with early HD the long-latency reflexes (LLR) were uni- or bilaterally absent in response to both median nerve and radial superficial nerve stimulation. The remaining patients had a diminished mean amplitude and mean duration of their LLR. In contrast, offspring and patients with symptomatic chorea had preserved LLR which did not differ in amplitude or duration from normal controls. Additionally, the mean amplitude and mean duration of the Hoffmaan-reflex (HR) was found to be increased in patients with HD and their offspring but not in patients with other aetiologies. It is concluded (1) that the loss of LLR is not related to the choreatic hyperkinesia itself but to the degeneration of a hitherto poorly defined neuronal circuit in HD; (2) that among a variety of diseases presenting with chorea, the loss of LLR seems to be specific for HD; (3) that the testing of hand muscle reflexes in choreatic movement disorders is helpful for the differential diagnosis of early HD but not for the detection of gene carriers among offspring of patients with HD.
在23例早期显性亨廷顿舞蹈病(HD)患者、17例HD患者的临床健康后代以及18例因HD以外各种病因导致的舞蹈样运动障碍患者中,研究了电刺激正中神经(包含本体感觉和皮肤传入神经)和桡浅神经(仅皮肤传入神经)后的鱼际反射。在61%的早期HD患者中,对正中神经和桡浅神经刺激的反应,长潜伏期反射(LLR)单侧或双侧缺失。其余患者的LLR平均波幅和平均时限减小。相比之下,有症状的舞蹈病患者及其后代的LLR保存完好,其波幅和时限与正常对照无差异。此外,发现HD患者及其后代的霍夫曼反射(HR)平均波幅和平均时限增加,而其他病因患者则无此现象。得出以下结论:(1)LLR缺失与舞蹈样运动障碍本身无关,而是与HD中迄今定义不清的神经回路退化有关;(2)在各种表现为舞蹈病的疾病中,LLR缺失似乎是HD所特有的;(3)在舞蹈样运动障碍中检测手部肌肉反射有助于早期HD的鉴别诊断,但无助于HD患者后代中基因携带者的检测。