Cantu Angel Marie, Hill Laura G, Becker Linda G
Thrive by Five Washington, US.
Washington State University, US.
J Child Serv. 2010;5(4):18-30. doi: 10.5042/jcs.2010.0692.
The aims of this study were to determine (1) the degree to which an evidence-based intervention (EBI) delivered outside the context of a research trial remained faithful to the content and design of the programme as intended and as reported in experimental trials of the same programme, and (2) whether implementation quality affected programme outcomes. We report results of an observational study of 11 sites involved in the statewide dissemination of a popular family-focused prevention programme, the Strengthening Families Programme for Parents and Youth 10-14. We found numerous differences between the community-based implementations we observed and researcher-driven implementations of the same programme, but variability in programme delivery and adherence to content were unrelated to programme outcomes. We conclude that short-term outcomes of well-designed EBIs delivered by well-trained facilitators may be robust to minor changes in delivery and content. However, the effects of implementation quality on longer-term outcomes are unknown.
(1)在研究试验背景之外实施的循证干预措施(EBI)在多大程度上忠实于该项目在相同项目的实验性试验中所预期和报告的内容及设计;(2)实施质量是否会影响项目结果。我们报告了一项观察性研究的结果,该研究涉及11个参与全州范围内一项广受欢迎的以家庭为重点的预防项目(即针对10 - 14岁父母与青少年的强化家庭项目)推广的地点。我们发现,我们观察到的基于社区的实施与研究人员主导的同一项目实施之间存在诸多差异,但项目实施的可变性以及对内容的遵守情况与项目结果无关。我们得出结论,由训练有素的促进者实施的精心设计的循证干预措施的短期结果可能对实施和内容的微小变化具有稳健性。然而,实施质量对长期结果的影响尚不清楚。