Gudlavalleti Murthy Venkata S, John Neena, Allagh Komal, Sagar Jayanthi, Kamalakannan Sureshkumar, Ramachandra Srikrishna S
South Asia Centre for Disability Inclusive Development and Research, Indian Institute of Public Health, Public Health Foundation of India, ANV Arcade, 1 Amar Cooperative Society, Kavuri Hills, Madhapur, Hyderabad 500033, India.
BMC Public Health. 2014 Nov 1;14:1125. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-14-1125.
Data shows that people with disability are more disadvantaged in accessing health, education and employment opportunities compared to people without a disability. There is a lack of credible documented evidence on health care access and barriers to access from India. The South India Disability Evidence (SIDE) Study was undertaken to understand the health needs of people with disabilities, and barriers to accessing health services.
The study was conducted in one district each in two States (Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka) in 2012. Appropriate age and sex-matched people without a disability were recruited to compare with people with disability who were identified through a population-based survey and available government disability records by trained key informants. These people were then examined by a medical team to confirm the diagnosis. Investigators administered questionnaire schedules to people with and without a disability to harness information on employment and health service access, utilization and barriers.
A total of 839 people with disabilities and 1153 age and sex matched people without a disability, aged 18 years or more were included. People with disability had significantly lower employment rates. On univariate analysis, people with disability (18.4%) needed to visit a hospital significantly more often in the preceding year compared to people without a disability (8.8%) (X2- 40.0562; P < =0.001). However adjusted odds ratios did not show a statistically significant difference. Significant differences were also observed with respect to past hospitalization. People with disabilities had 4.6 times higher risk of suffering from diabetes and 5.8 times higher risk of suffering from depression compared to people without a disability and the risk was significantly higher in males compared to females with disability. People with disability faced significantly more barriers to accessing health services compared to people without a disability. Barriers included ignorance regarding availability of services, costs of services and transportation.
This study highlights the challenges that people with disability face in accessing health-care and employment opportunities. The study findings have public health implications and should be used for planning need-based appropriate strategies to improve health care access for people with disabilities.
数据显示,与非残疾人士相比,残疾人士在获得医疗、教育和就业机会方面处于更为不利的地位。印度缺乏关于医疗保健获取情况及获取障碍的可靠书面证据。开展南印度残疾证据(SIDE)研究旨在了解残疾人士的健康需求以及获取医疗服务的障碍。
2012年在两个邦(安得拉邦和卡纳塔克邦)各一个地区开展了该研究。招募了年龄和性别匹配的非残疾人士,与通过基于人群的调查以及训练有素的关键信息提供者提供的现有政府残疾记录确定的残疾人士进行比较。然后由医疗团队对这些人进行检查以确诊。研究人员向残疾和非残疾人士发放问卷,以收集有关就业以及医疗服务获取、利用和障碍方面的信息。
共纳入了839名18岁及以上的残疾人士以及1153名年龄和性别匹配的非残疾人士。残疾人士的就业率显著更低。单因素分析显示,与非残疾人士(8.8%)相比,残疾人士(18.4%)在前一年需要更频繁地前往医院就诊(X2 = 40.0562;P <= 0.001)。然而,调整后的比值比未显示出统计学上的显著差异。在过去住院情况方面也观察到了显著差异。与非残疾人士相比,残疾人士患糖尿病的风险高4.6倍,患抑郁症的风险高5.8倍,且男性残疾人士的风险显著高于女性残疾人士。与非残疾人士相比,残疾人士在获取医疗服务方面面临的障碍显著更多。障碍包括对服务可及性、服务费用和交通的无知。
本研究突出了残疾人士在获取医疗保健和就业机会方面面临的挑战。研究结果具有公共卫生意义,应用于制定基于需求的适当策略,以改善残疾人士的医疗保健获取情况。