Agius Steven J, Brockbank Amy, Baron Rebecca, Farook Saleem, Hayden Jacky
North Western Deanery, Health Education England (North West), Manchester, UK.
J Health Organ Manag. 2015;29(1):39-54. doi: 10.1108/JHOM-09-2013-0188.
The purpose of this paper is to determine the impact of an integrated Medical Leadership Programme (MLP) on a cohort of participating specialty doctors and the NHS services with which they were engaged.
DESIGN/METHODOLOGY/APPROACH: This was a qualitative study designed to obtain rich textual data on a novel training intervention. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with participating MLP trainees at fixed points throughout the programme in order to capture their experiences. Resulting data were triangulated with data from extant documentation, including trainees' progress reports and summaries of achievements. Recurring discourses and themes were identified using a framework thematic analysis.
Evidence of the positive impact upon trainees and NHS services was identified, along with challenges. Evidence of impact across all the domains within the national Medical Leadership Competency Framework was also identified, including demonstrating personal qualities, working with others, managing services, improving services and setting direction.
RESEARCH LIMITATIONS/IMPLICATIONS: Data were drawn from interviews with a small population of trainees undertaking a pilot MLP in a single deanery, so there are inevitable limitations for generalisability in the quantitative sense. Whilst the pilot trainees were a self-selected group, it was a group of mixed origin and ability.
The study has provided valuable lessons for the design of future leadership programmes aimed at doctors in training.
ORIGINALITY/VALUE: Identifying the effectiveness of an innovative model of delivery with regard to the Medical Leadership Curriculum may assist with medical staff engagement and support health service improvements to benefit patient care.
本文旨在确定综合医学领导力项目(MLP)对一批参与项目的专科医生及其所服务的国民医疗服务体系(NHS)的影响。
设计/方法/途径:这是一项定性研究,旨在获取有关一项新型培训干预措施的丰富文本数据。在整个项目过程中的固定时间点,对参与MLP的学员进行了半结构化访谈,以了解他们的经历。将所得数据与现有文档中的数据进行三角验证,这些文档包括学员的进度报告和成绩总结。使用框架主题分析法确定反复出现的话语和主题。
确定了该项目对学员和NHS服务产生积极影响的证据,同时也发现了一些挑战。还确定了在国家医学领导力能力框架内所有领域的影响证据,包括展示个人品质、与他人合作、管理服务、改善服务和设定方向。
研究局限性/启示:数据来自对在单一教区参加MLP试点项目的一小部分学员的访谈,因此在定量意义上的普遍性存在不可避免的局限性。虽然试点学员是一个自我选择的群体,但他们来自不同背景且能力各异。
该研究为未来针对实习医生的领导力项目设计提供了宝贵经验。
原创性/价值:确定一种创新的医学领导力课程授课模式的有效性,可能有助于医护人员参与并支持医疗服务改进,从而使患者护理受益。