Lytle Nicole, London Kamala, Bruck Maggie
Department of Psychology, University of Toledo, Toledo, OH 43606, USA.
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Johns Hopkins Medical Institution, Baltimore, MD 21205, USA.
J Exp Child Psychol. 2015 Jun;134:30-42. doi: 10.1016/j.jecp.2015.01.010. Epub 2015 Mar 19.
In two experiments, we investigated 3- to 5-year-old children's ability to use dolls and human figure drawings as symbols to map body touches. In Experiment 1, stickers were placed on different locations of children's bodies, and the children were asked to indicate the locations of the stickers using three different symbols: a doll, a human figure drawing, and the adult researcher. Performance on the tasks increased with age, but many 5-year-olds did not attain perfect performance. Surprisingly, younger children made more errors on the two-dimensional (2D) human figure drawing task compared with the three-dimensional (3D) doll and adult tasks. In Experiment 2, we compared children's ability to use 3D and 2D symbols to indicate body touch as well as to guide their search for a hidden object. We replicated the findings of Experiment 1 for the body touch task; for younger children, 3D symbols were easier to use than 2D symbols. However, the reverse pattern was found for the object locations task, with children showing superior performance using 2D drawings over 3D models. Although children showed developmental improvements in using dolls and drawings to show where they were touched, less than two thirds of the 5-year-olds performed perfectly on the touch tasks. Both developmental and forensic implications of these results are discussed.
在两项实验中,我们研究了3至5岁儿童使用玩偶和人体绘图作为符号来标记身体触摸位置的能力。在实验1中,贴纸被贴在儿童身体的不同部位,然后要求儿童使用三种不同的符号来指出贴纸的位置:一个玩偶、一幅人体绘图和成年研究者。任务表现随年龄增长而提高,但许多5岁儿童并未达到完美表现。令人惊讶的是,与三维(3D)玩偶和成年研究者任务相比,年幼儿童在二维(2D)人体绘图任务上犯的错误更多。在实验2中,我们比较了儿童使用3D和2D符号来指示身体触摸位置以及指导他们寻找隐藏物体的能力。我们在身体触摸任务上重复了实验1的结果;对于年幼儿童来说,3D符号比2D符号更容易使用。然而,在物体位置任务上发现了相反的模式,儿童使用2D绘图比3D模型表现更好。尽管儿童在使用玩偶和绘图来展示他们被触摸的位置方面有了发展上的进步,但在触摸任务中,不到三分之二的5岁儿童表现完美。我们讨论了这些结果在发展和法医学方面的意义。