Boudioni Markella, Hallett Nina, Lora Cristina, Couchman Wendy
Patient Experience Research Centre (PERC) and NIHR Imperial Biomedical Research Centre (BRC), Imperial College London, London South Bank University, London, UK.
Faculty of Health and Social Care, London South Bank University, London, UK.
Patient Prefer Adherence. 2015 Mar 30;9:529-40. doi: 10.2147/PPA.S77573. eCollection 2015.
This article presents the emotional journey and experience of powerlessness of integrated care service users and carers.
The experiences of seven integrated care service users and carers affected by complex conditions in a London borough were captured as video stories. The integrated care service coordinated a system of health and social care: primary care, community matrons, social workers, and the voluntary sector. The service was designed to respond to identified cases of high-risk individuals with long-term, multiple, and age-related conditions needing preventive interventions. The video stories were analyzed by researchers in collaboration with service users using a visual thematic qualitative approach. This report is part of an independent analysis of the integrated care service evaluation that used the experience-based codesign model.
The findings are presented in the respective contexts of people with complex conditions and their carers. The overwhelming feelings and emotions of both were loss of control and power throughout their emotional journey, with family carers adopting a protective attitude toward the patients. Their experience of powerlessness was variable throughout their emotional journey. They were affected more strongly when in need of extra help and support and while they were undergoing the process of receiving extra services. When they were receiving help and support outside and within hospitals, some participants were empowered, gaining skills and knowledge by being provided with the mechanisms to cope with their condition at present and in the future.
Feelings of powerlessness were very common among integrated care service users and their carers. Powerless/empowerment has been poorly investigated to date. Visual methods and collaborative visual analysis with service users have proved to be powerful methods too, but have been rarely reported.
本文介绍了综合护理服务使用者和护理人员的情感历程及无助体验。
以视频故事的形式记录了伦敦一个行政区内七名受复杂病情影响的综合护理服务使用者和护理人员的经历。综合护理服务协调了一个健康与社会护理系统,包括初级护理、社区护士长、社会工作者和志愿部门。该服务旨在应对已确定的高风险个体案例,这些个体患有长期、多种且与年龄相关的疾病,需要预防性干预措施。研究人员与服务使用者合作,采用视觉主题定性方法对视频故事进行了分析。本报告是对使用基于经验的协同设计模型的综合护理服务评估进行独立分析的一部分。
研究结果分别在患有复杂病情的人群及其护理人员的背景下呈现。两者压倒性的感受和情绪是在整个情感历程中失去控制和权力,家庭护理人员对患者采取保护态度。他们的无助体验在整个情感历程中各不相同。在需要额外帮助和支持时以及接受额外服务的过程中,他们受到的影响更大。当他们在医院内外接受帮助和支持时,一些参与者获得了力量,通过获得应对当前和未来病情的机制而获得了技能和知识。
无助感在综合护理服务使用者及其护理人员中非常普遍。迄今为止,对无助/赋权的研究较少。视觉方法以及与服务使用者进行的协作式视觉分析已被证明也是有效的方法,但很少有相关报道。