Rathore Farooq Azam, Waqas Ahmed, Zia Ahmad Marjan, Mavrinac Martina, Farooq Fareeha
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, Combined Military Hospital , Lahore Cantt , Pakistan.
CMH Lahore Medical College and Dental College , Lahore Cantt , Pakistan.
PeerJ. 2015 Jun 18;3:e1031. doi: 10.7717/peerj.1031. eCollection 2015.
Objective. The objective of this survey was to explore the attitudes towards plagiarism of faculty members and medical students in Pakistan. Methods. The Attitudes Toward Plagiarism questionnaire (ATP) was modified and distributed among 550 medical students and 130 faculty members in 7 medical colleges of Lahore and Rawalpindi. Data was entered in the SPSS v.20 and descriptive statistics were analyzed. The questionnaire was validated by principal axis factoring analysis. Results. Response rate was 93% and 73%, respectively. Principal axis factoring analysis confirmed one factor structure of ATP in the present sample. It had an acceptable Cronbach's alpha value of 0.73. There were 421 medical students (218 (52%) female, 46% 3rd year MBBS students, mean age of 20.93 ± 1.4 years) and 95 faculty members (54.7% female, mean age 34.5 ± 8.9 years). One fifth of the students (19.7%) trained in medical writing (19.7%), research ethics (25.2%) or were currently involved in medical writing (17.6%). Most of the faculty members were demonstrators (66) or assistant professors (20) with work experience between 1 and 10 years. Most of them had trained in medical writing (68), research ethics (64) and were currently involved in medical writing (64). Medical students and faculty members had a mean score of 43.21 (7.1) and 48.4 (5.9) respectively on ATP. Most of the respondents did not consider that they worked in a plagiarism free environment and reported that self-plagiarism should not be punishable in the same way as plagiarism. Opinion regarding leniency in punishment of younger researchers who were just learning medical writing was divided. Conclusions. The general attitudes of Pakistani medical faculty members and medical students as assessed by ATP were positive. We propose training in medical writing and research ethics as part of the under and post graduate medical curriculum.
目的。本次调查的目的是探究巴基斯坦教职员工和医学生对抄袭行为的态度。方法。对《抄袭态度问卷》(ATP)进行修改,并在拉合尔和拉瓦尔品第的7所医学院校的550名医学生和130名教职员工中进行发放。数据录入SPSS v.20并进行描述性统计分析。该问卷通过主轴因子分析进行了验证。结果。回复率分别为93%和73%。主轴因子分析证实了本样本中ATP的单因素结构。其Cronbach's alpha值为0.73,可接受。有421名医学生(218名(52%)为女性,46%为医学学士三年级学生,平均年龄20.93±1.4岁)和95名教职员工(54.7%为女性,平均年龄34.5±8.9岁)。五分之一的学生接受过医学写作培训(19.7%)、研究伦理培训(25.2%)或目前从事医学写作工作(17.6%)。大多数教职员工是 demonstrators(66名)或助理教授(20名),工作经验在1至10年之间。他们中的大多数接受过医学写作培训(68名)、研究伦理培训(64名)且目前从事医学写作工作(64名)。医学生和教职员工在ATP上的平均得分分别为43.21(7.1)和48.4(5.9)。大多数受访者认为他们并非在无抄袭的环境中工作,并表示自我抄袭不应与抄袭受到同等惩罚。对于刚学习医学写作的年轻研究人员在惩罚上是否应从轻处理,意见存在分歧。结论。通过ATP评估,巴基斯坦医学教职员工和医学生的总体态度是积极的。我们建议将医学写作和研究伦理培训作为本科和研究生医学课程的一部分。