Hadjipavlou George, Hernandez Carlos A Sierra, Ogrodniczuk John S
Assistant Professor, Department of Psychiatry, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia.
Graduate Student, Department of Psychology, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, British Columbia.
Can J Psychiatry. 2015 Jun;60(6):294-300. doi: 10.1177/070674371506000609.
American data suggest a declining trend in the provision of psychotherapy by psychiatrists. Nevertheless, the extent to which such findings generalize to psychiatric practice in other countries is unclear. We surveyed psychiatrists in British Columbia to examine whether the reported decline in psychotherapy provision extends to the landscape of Canadian psychiatric practice.
A survey was mailed to the entire population of fully licensed psychiatrists registered in British Columbia (n = 623). The survey consisted of 30 items. Descriptive statistics were used to characterize the sample and psychotherapy practice patterns. Associations between variables were evaluated using nonparametric tests.
A total of 423 psychiatrists returned the survey, yielding a response rate of 68%. Overall, 80.9% of psychiatrists (n = 342) reported practicing psychotherapy. A decline in the provision of psychotherapy was not observed; in fact, there was an increase in psychotherapy provision among psychiatrists entering practice in the last 10 years. Individual therapy was the predominant format used by psychiatrists. The most common primary theoretical orientation was psychodynamic (29.9%). Regarding actual practice, supportive psychotherapy was practiced most frequently. Professional time constraints were perceived as the most significant barrier to providing psychotherapy. The majority (85%) of clinicians did not view remuneration as a significant barrier to treating patients with psychotherapy.
Our findings challenge the prevailing view that psychotherapy is in decline among psychiatrists. Psychiatrists in British Columbia continue to integrate psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy in clinical practice, thus preserving their unique place in the spectrum of mental health services.
美国的数据表明精神科医生提供心理治疗的趋势在下降。然而,这些发现能在多大程度上推广到其他国家的精神科实践尚不清楚。我们对不列颠哥伦比亚省的精神科医生进行了调查,以研究报告中提到的心理治疗提供量下降的情况是否也适用于加拿大的精神科实践领域。
向在不列颠哥伦比亚省注册的所有完全持证精神科医生(n = 623)邮寄了一份调查问卷。该问卷包含30个项目。描述性统计用于描述样本和心理治疗实践模式。使用非参数检验评估变量之间的关联。
共有423名精神科医生回复了调查问卷,回复率为68%。总体而言,80.9%的精神科医生(n = 342)报告从事心理治疗。未观察到心理治疗提供量的下降;事实上,在过去10年开始执业的精神科医生中,心理治疗的提供量有所增加。个体治疗是精神科医生使用的主要形式。最常见的主要理论取向是心理动力学(29.9%)。在实际实践中,支持性心理治疗最为常用。专业时间限制被认为是提供心理治疗的最主要障碍。大多数临床医生(85%)不认为薪酬是用心理治疗治疗患者的重大障碍。
我们的研究结果挑战了普遍观点,即精神科医生提供心理治疗的情况在下降。不列颠哥伦比亚省的精神科医生在临床实践中继续将心理治疗和药物治疗相结合,从而在心理健康服务领域保持其独特地位。