Allen Sarah Leatherman, Davis Kimberly S, Rousseau Paul C, Iverson Patty J, Mauldin Patrick D, Moran William P
J Grad Med Educ. 2015 Mar;7(1):91-4. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-14-00145.1.
Advanced care directives (ACDs) and end-of-life discussions are important and typically difficult to initiate because of the sensitive nature of the topic and competing clinical priorities. Resident physicians need to have these conversations but often do not in their continuity clinics.
We implemented a program to (1) increase physician opportunity to discuss end-of-life wishes with their patients, and (2) improve residents' confidence in leading discussions regarding ACDs.
A total of 95 residents in an academic outpatient internal medicine resident continuity clinic participated in a formalized curriculum (didactic sessions, simulations, and academic detailing). Clinic workflow alterations prompted the staff to question if patients had an ACD or living will, and then cued residents to discuss these issues with the patients if they did not.
Of the 77% of patients who were asked about ACDs, 74% had no ACD but were interested in discussing this topic. After our intervention, 65% (62 of 95) of our residents reported having at least 1 outpatient discussion with their patients. Residents reported increased confidence directing and discussing advanced care planning with older patients and conducting a family meeting (P < .01).
By delivering a formalized curriculum and creating a clinical environment that supports such discussions, resident physicians had more ACD discussions with their patients and reported increased confidence. When provided information and opportunity, patients consistently expressed interest in talking with their physician about their advanced care wishes.
高级医疗指令(ACD)和临终讨论很重要,但由于话题的敏感性和相互冲突的临床优先事项,通常很难启动。住院医师需要进行这些谈话,但在他们的连续性门诊中往往不会这样做。
我们实施了一个项目,以(1)增加医生与患者讨论临终愿望的机会,以及(2)提高住院医师主导关于高级医疗指令讨论的信心。
一所学术性门诊内科住院医师连续性诊所的95名住院医师参加了一个正式课程(理论课程、模拟和学术指导)。诊所工作流程的改变促使工作人员询问患者是否有高级医疗指令或生前预嘱,如果没有,就提示住院医师与患者讨论这些问题。
在被询问高级医疗指令的患者中,77%的患者没有高级医疗指令,但有兴趣讨论这个话题。在我们的干预之后,65%(95名中的62名)的住院医师报告至少与他们的患者进行了1次门诊讨论。住院医师报告在指导和与老年患者讨论高级医疗规划以及召开家庭会议方面的信心有所增强(P < 0.01)。
通过提供一个正式课程并营造一个支持此类讨论的临床环境,住院医师与他们的患者进行了更多关于高级医疗指令的讨论,并报告信心有所增强。当获得信息和机会时,患者始终表达出与他们的医生谈论其高级医疗愿望的兴趣。