Clarkson Eric, Cushing Johnathan B
J Opt Soc Am A Opt Image Sci Vis. 2015 Jul 1;32(7):1288-301. doi: 10.1364/JOSAA.32.001288.
Shannon information (SI) and the ideal-observer receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve are two different methods for analyzing the performance of an imaging system for a binary classification task, such as the detection of a variable signal embedded within a random background. In this work we describe a new ROC curve, the Shannon information receiver operator curve (SIROC), that is derived from the SI expression for a binary classification task. We then show that the ideal-observer ROC curve and the SIROC have many properties in common, and are equivalent descriptions of the optimal performance of an observer on the task. This equivalence is described mathematically by an integral transform that maps the ideal-observer ROC curve onto the SIROC. This then leads to an integral transform relating the minimum probability of error, as a function of the odds against a signal, to the conditional entropy, as a function of the same variable. This last relation then gives us the complete mathematical equivalence between ideal-observer ROC analysis and SI analysis of the classification task for a given imaging system. We also find that there is a close relationship between the area under the ideal-observer ROC curve, which is often used as a figure of merit for imaging systems and the area under the SIROC. Finally, we show that the relationships between the two curves result in new inequalities relating SI to ROC quantities for the ideal observer.
香农信息(SI)和理想观察者接收者操作特征(ROC)曲线是分析成像系统在二元分类任务(如检测嵌入随机背景中的可变信号)中性能的两种不同方法。在这项工作中,我们描述了一种新的ROC曲线,即香农信息接收者操作曲线(SIROC),它是从二元分类任务的SI表达式推导出来的。然后我们表明,理想观察者ROC曲线和SIROC有许多共同特性,并且是观察者在该任务上最优性能的等效描述。这种等效性通过一种积分变换在数学上进行描述,该变换将理想观察者ROC曲线映射到SIROC上。这进而导致一种积分变换,将作为信号反对率函数的最小错误概率与作为相同变量函数的条件熵联系起来。最后这种关系给出了给定成像系统分类任务的理想观察者ROC分析和SI分析之间的完全数学等效性。我们还发现,常用于衡量成像系统品质因数的理想观察者ROC曲线下的面积与SIROC曲线下的面积之间存在密切关系。最后,我们表明两条曲线之间的关系导致了关于理想观察者的SI与ROC量之间的新不等式。