Zanolie Kiki, de Cremer David, Güroğlu Berna, Crone Eveline A
Institute of Psychology, Leiden University, Leiden, the Netherlands; Leiden Institute for Brain and Cognition (LIBC), Leiden University, Leiden, the Netherlands.
Judge Business School, Cambridge University, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2015 Oct 7;10(10):e0139953. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0139953. eCollection 2015.
The neural correlates of rejection in bargaining situations when proposing a fair or unfair offer are not yet well understood. We measured neural responses to rejection and acceptance of monetary offers with event-related potentials (ERPs) in mid-adolescents (14-17 years) and early adults (19-24 years). Participants played multiple rounds of the Ultimatum Game as proposers, dividing coins between themselves and a second player (responder) by making a choice between an unfair distribution (7 coins for proposer and 3 for responder; 7/3) and one of two alternatives: a fair distribution (5/5) or a hyperfair distribution (3/7). Participants mostly made fair offers (5/5) when the alternative was unfair (7/3), but made mostly unfair offers (7/3) when the alternative was hyperfair (3/7). When participants' fair offers (5/5; alternative was 7/3) were rejected this was associated with a larger Medial Frontal Negativity (MFN) compared to acceptance of fair offers and rejection of unfair offers (7/3; alternative was 3/7). Also, the MFN was smaller after acceptance of unfair offers (7/3) compared to rejection. These neural responses did not differ between adults and mid-adolescents, suggesting that the MFN reacts as a neural alarm system to social prediction errors which is already prevalent during adolescence.
在提出公平或不公平提议的讨价还价情境中,拒绝的神经关联尚未得到充分理解。我们使用事件相关电位(ERP)测量了青少年中期(14 - 17岁)和青年早期(19 - 24岁)对金钱提议被拒绝和接受时的神经反应。参与者作为提议者进行多轮最后通牒博弈,通过在不公平分配(提议者7枚硬币,回应者3枚硬币;7/3)与两种选择之一之间做出选择,在自己和第二名玩家(回应者)之间分配硬币:公平分配(5/5)或超公平分配(3/7)。当替代方案不公平(7/3)时,参与者大多提出公平提议(5/5),但当替代方案是超公平(3/7)时,参与者大多提出不公平提议(7/3)。当参与者的公平提议(5/5;替代方案是7/3)被拒绝时,与接受公平提议和拒绝不公平提议(7/3;替代方案是3/7)相比,这与更大的内侧额叶负波(MFN)相关。此外,与被拒绝相比,接受不公平提议(7/3)后MFN较小。这些神经反应在成年人和青少年中期之间没有差异,表明MFN作为一种神经警报系统对社会预测误差做出反应,这种反应在青春期已经很普遍。