Shephard R J
School of Physical and Health Education, Department of Preventive Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Br J Sports Med. 1989 Mar;23(1):11-22. doi: 10.1136/bjsm.23.1.11.
While the evidence for a clustering of health habits is not particularly strong, there are both pedagogic and economic arguments in favour of a multifaceted approach to health education. The present review thus examines the impact of regular physical exercise upon other forms of health behaviour, testing the extent to which an activity programme can be a catalyst of improved lifestyle in both primary and secondary preventive therapy. The conceptual framework of health promotion is examined with particular reference to the models of Skinner, Becker, Fishbein, Triandis and Rokeach. Certain differences are noted between the decision to exercise and the marketing decisions for which Fishbein's model was originally designed. Nevertheless, in its later modifications, it provides a basic framework for understanding how human lifestyle is shaped. Theoretical mechanisms are suggested whereby exercise could influence such behaviours as cigarette smoking, alcohol consumption and drug usage, seat-belt usage, hypertension, body mass, lipid profile, promiscuous sexual behaviour, the carrying of lethal weapons, and acceptance of regular preventive medical examinations. The empirical evidence from both cross-sectional and longitudinal experiments shows a relatively weak association between exercise habits and other desirable forms of health behaviour. Moreover, it is arguable that other forms of health intervention such as smoking withdrawal or dieting might be equally effective as a primary change agent, and much of the observed association between exercise and other health habits could be attributable to a common dependence on demographic and socio-economic factors. On the other hand, the apparent weakness of associations may arise in part from difficulties in measuring both habitual physical activity and other forms of health behaviour, with a resultant attenuation of correlations. Possibly, a stronger association between exercise participation and other favourable health habits would be uncovered if attention were focused upon those forms of endurance exercise currently thought to enhance cardiac health. Given that moderate endurance exercise is also positive and pleasant advice, further examination of the potential of multifaceted but exercise-centered health promotion programmes appears warranted.
虽然健康习惯聚集的证据不是特别有力,但在健康教育中采用多方面的方法有教学和经济两方面的论据支持。因此,本综述考察了定期体育锻炼对其他健康行为形式的影响,检验了一项活动计划在初级和二级预防治疗中能在多大程度上成为改善生活方式的催化剂。特别参照斯金纳、贝克尔、费什拜因、特里安德斯和罗基奇的模型对健康促进的概念框架进行了考察。注意到决定锻炼与费什拜因模型最初所设计的营销决策之间存在某些差异。然而,在其后来的修正中,它为理解人类生活方式是如何形成的提供了一个基本框架。提出了理论机制,据此锻炼可能会影响诸如吸烟、饮酒和吸毒、使用安全带、高血压、体重、血脂状况、滥交性行为、携带致命武器以及接受定期预防性体检等行为。横断面和纵向实验的经验证据表明,锻炼习惯与其他理想的健康行为形式之间的关联相对较弱。此外,可以认为其他形式的健康干预,如戒烟或节食,作为主要的改变因素可能同样有效,而且观察到的锻炼与其他健康习惯之间的许多关联可能归因于对人口统计学和社会经济因素的共同依赖。另一方面,关联的明显薄弱可能部分源于在测量习惯性体育活动和其他健康行为形式方面存在困难,从而导致相关性减弱。如果将注意力集中在目前认为能增强心脏健康的那些耐力锻炼形式上,可能会发现锻炼参与与其他有利健康习惯之间有更强的关联。鉴于适度的耐力锻炼也是积极且有益的建议,进一步研究多方面但以锻炼为中心的健康促进计划的潜力似乎是有必要的。