Veloz Tomas, Desjardins Sylvie
Department of Mathematics, University of British Columbia Kelowna, BC, Canada ; Center Leo Apostel, Vrije Universiteit Brussel Brussels, Belgium ; Instituto de Filosofía y Ciencias de la Complejidad - IFICC Ñuñoa, Chile.
Department of Mathematics, University of British Columbia Kelowna, BC, Canada.
Front Psychol. 2015 Nov 12;6:1734. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2015.01734. eCollection 2015.
Quantum models of concept combinations have been successful in representing various experimental situations that cannot be accommodated by traditional models based on classical probability or fuzzy set theory. In many cases, the focus has been on producing a representation that fits experimental results to validate quantum models. However, these representations are not always consistent with the cognitive modeling principles. Moreover, some important issues related to the representation of concepts such as the dimensionality of the realization space, the uniqueness of solutions, and the compatibility of measurements, have been overlooked. In this paper, we provide a dimensional analysis of the realization space for the two-sector Fock space model for conjunction of concepts focusing on the first and second sectors separately. We then introduce various representation of concepts that arise from the use of unitary operators in the realization space. In these concrete representations, a pair of concepts and their combination are modeled by a single conceptual state, and by a collection of exemplar-dependent operators. Therefore, they are consistent with cognitive modeling principles. This framework not only provides a uniform approach to model an entire data set, but, because all measurement operators are expressed in the same basis, allows us to address the question of compatibility of measurements. In particular, we present evidence that it may be possible to predict non-commutative effects from partial measurements of conceptual combinations.
概念组合的量子模型已成功地表示了各种传统模型(基于经典概率或模糊集理论)无法适应的实验情况。在许多情况下,重点在于生成一个与实验结果相符的表示,以验证量子模型。然而,这些表示并不总是与认知建模原则一致。此外,一些与概念表示相关的重要问题,如实现空间的维度、解的唯一性以及测量的兼容性,都被忽视了。在本文中,我们对用于概念合取的两部分福克空间模型的实现空间进行维度分析,分别聚焦于第一部分和第二部分。然后,我们介绍了在实现空间中使用酉算子所产生的各种概念表示。在这些具体表示中,一对概念及其组合由单个概念状态以及一组依赖于范例的算子来建模。因此,它们与认知建模原则一致。这个框架不仅提供了一种统一的方法来对整个数据集进行建模,而且由于所有测量算子都以相同的基表示,使我们能够解决测量兼容性的问题。特别是,我们提供了证据表明,从概念组合的部分测量中可能预测出非对易效应。