Ayanore Martin Amogre, Pavlova Milena, Groot Wim
Department of Health Services Research, CAPHRI, Maastricht University Medical Centre, Faculty of Health, Medicine and Life Sciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Top Institute Evidence-Based Education Research (TIER), Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Reprod Health. 2016 Jan 16;13:5. doi: 10.1186/s12978-015-0104-x.
Identifying relevant measures of women's reproductive health needs is critical to improve women's chances of service utilization. The study aims to systematically review and analyze the adequacy of outcome measures and determinants applied in previous studies for assessing women reproductive health needs across West Africa.
Evidence on outcomes and determinants of unmet reproductive health needs among women of childbearing age in diverse multicultural, religious, and ethnic settings in West African countries was systematically reviewed. The review included recent English language publications (from January 2009 - March 2014). Clinical studies particularly on obstetric care services and reproductive services in relation to HIV/AIDS were excluded. We acknowledge the possibility to have excluded non-English publications and yet-to-be-published articles related to the study aim and objectives. Outcomes and determinants were assessed and defined at three main levels; contraceptive use, obstetric care, and antenatal care utilization.
Results show increasing unmet need for women's reproductive health needs. Socio-cultural norms and practices resulting in discontinuation of service use, economic constraints, travel distance to access services and low education levels of women were found to be key predictors of service utilization for contraception, antenatal and obstetric care services. Outcome measures were mainly assessed based on service utilization, satisfaction, cost, and quality of services available as core measures across the three levels assessed in this review.
Evidence from this review indicates that currently applied measures of women's reproductive health needs might be inadequate in attaining best maternal outcomes since they appear rather broad. More support and research for developing and advancing context-related measures may help to improve women's maternal health.
确定妇女生殖健康需求的相关衡量标准对于提高妇女获得服务的机会至关重要。本研究旨在系统回顾和分析以往研究中用于评估西非妇女生殖健康需求的结果指标和决定因素的充分性。
系统回顾了西非国家多元文化、宗教和种族背景下育龄妇女未满足生殖健康需求的结果和决定因素的证据。该综述纳入了近期的英文出版物(2009年1月至2014年3月)。排除了特别是关于产科护理服务以及与艾滋病毒/艾滋病相关的生殖服务的临床研究。我们承认有可能排除了与研究目的相关的非英文出版物和尚未发表的文章。在避孕、产科护理和产前护理利用三个主要层面评估和定义了结果和决定因素。
结果显示,妇女对生殖健康需求的未满足情况在增加。导致服务使用中断的社会文化规范和习俗、经济限制、获取服务的出行距离以及妇女的低教育水平被发现是避孕、产前和产科护理服务利用的关键预测因素。在本综述评估的三个层面中,结果指标主要基于服务利用、满意度、成本以及现有服务质量作为核心指标进行评估。
本次综述的证据表明,目前应用的妇女生殖健康需求衡量标准可能不足以实现最佳的孕产妇结局,因为它们显得较为宽泛。更多支持以及开展与背景相关的措施的研究可能有助于改善妇女的孕产妇健康。