Vashi Pankaj, Edwin Persis, Popiel Brenten, Lammersfeld Carolyn, Gupta Digant
Cancer Treatment Centers of America® (CTCA) at Midwestern Regional Medical Center, 2520 Elisha Ave, Zion, Illinois, 60099, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2016 Jan 25;11(1):e0147843. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0147843. eCollection 2016.
BACKGROUND/AIMS: Normal or high serum vitamin B-12 levels can sometimes be seen in a B-12 deficient state, and can therefore be misleading. High levels of Methymalonic Acid (MMA) and Homocysteine (HC) have been identified as better indicators of B-12 deficiency than the actual serum B-12 level itself. We evaluated the prevalence of vitamin B-12 deficiency using appropriate cut-off levels of vitamin B-12, MMA and HC, and determined the relationship between serum levels of vitamin B-12, MMA and HC in cancer.
This is a cross-sectional study using a consecutive case series of 316 cancer patients first seen at Cancer Treatment Centers of America® (CTCA) at Midwestern Regional Medical Center between April 2014 and June 2014. All patients were evaluated at baseline for vitamin B-12 (pg/mL), MMA (nmol/L) and HC (μmol/L) levels. In accordance with previously published research, the following cut-offs were used to define vitamin B-12 deficiency: <300 pg/mL for vitamin B-12, >260 nmol/L for MMA and >12 μmol/L for HC. The relationship between B-12, MMA and HC was evaluated using Spearman's rho correlation coefficient and cross-tabulation analysis. Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves were estimated using the non-parametric method to further evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of vitamin B-12 using Fedosov quotient as the "gold standard".
Mean age at presentation was 52.5 years. 134 (42.4%) patients were males while 182 (57.6%) were females. Median vitamin B-12, MMA and HC levels were 582.5 pg/mL, 146.5 nmol/L and 8.4 μmol/L respectively. Of 316 patients, 28 (8.9%) were vitamin B-12 deficient based on vitamin B-12 (<300 pg/mL), 34 (10.8%) were deficient based on MMA (>260 nmol/L) while 55 (17.4%) were deficient based on HC (>12 μmol/L). Correlation analysis revealed a significant weak negative correlation between vitamin B-12 and MMA (rho = -0.22) as well as B-12 and HC (rho = -0.35). ROC curves suggested MMA to have the best discriminatory power in predicting B-12 deficiency.
Vitamin B-12 is poorly correlated with MMA and HC in cancer. Using serum vitamin B-12 alone to evaluate B-12 status in cancer may fail to identify those with functional deficiency. A thorough clinical assessment is important to identify patients that may have risk factors and/or symptoms suggestive of deficiency. These patients should have additional testing of MMA and HC regardless of their B-12 levels.
背景/目的:在维生素B-12缺乏状态下,有时会出现血清维生素B-12水平正常或升高的情况,因此可能产生误导。已确定高甲基丙二酸(MMA)和高半胱氨酸(HC)水平比实际血清维生素B-12水平本身更能准确指示维生素B-12缺乏。我们使用适当的维生素B-12、MMA和HC临界值评估维生素B-12缺乏的患病率,并确定癌症患者血清中维生素B-12、MMA和HC水平之间的关系。
这是一项横断面研究,采用了2014年4月至2014年6月在美国中西部地区医疗中心美国癌症治疗中心(CTCA)首次就诊的316例癌症患者的连续病例系列。所有患者在基线时均接受维生素B-12(pg/mL)、MMA(nmol/L)和HC(μmol/L)水平评估。根据先前发表的研究,使用以下临界值定义维生素B-12缺乏:维生素B-12<300 pg/mL,MMA>260 nmol/L,HC>12 μmol/L。使用Spearman等级相关系数和交叉表分析评估B-12、MMA和HC之间的关系。采用非参数方法估计受试者工作特征(ROC)曲线,以费多索夫商数作为“金标准”进一步评估维生素B-12的诊断准确性。
就诊时的平均年龄为52.5岁。134例(42.4%)患者为男性,182例(57.6%)为女性。维生素B-12、MMA和HC的中位数水平分别为582.5 pg/mL、146.5 nmol/L和8.4 μmol/L。在316例患者中,基于维生素B-12(<300 pg/mL)有28例(8.9%)维生素B-12缺乏,基于MMA(>260 nmol/L)有34例(10.8%)缺乏,基于HC(>12 μmol/L)有55例(17.4%)缺乏。相关性分析显示维生素B-12与MMA(rho=-0.22)以及B-12与HC(rho=-0.35)之间存在显著的弱负相关。ROC曲线表明MMA在预测B-12缺乏方面具有最佳的鉴别能力。
在癌症患者中,维生素B-12与MMA和HC的相关性较差。仅使用血清维生素B-12来评估癌症患者的B-12状态可能无法识别出存在功能性缺乏的患者。进行全面的临床评估对于识别可能存在危险因素和/或提示缺乏症状的患者很重要。无论其B-12水平如何,这些患者都应进行MMA和HC的额外检测。