Chu Virginia Way, Park Se-Woong, Sanger Terence D, Sternad Dagmar
IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng. 2016 Aug;24(8):847-858. doi: 10.1109/TNSRE.2016.2521404. Epub 2016 Jan 25.
Children with dystonia are characterized by highly variable and seemingly uncontrolled movements. An important question for any rehabilitative effort is whether these children can learn and improve their performance. This study compared children with dystonia due to cerebral palsy, typically developing children, and healthy adults in their ability to acquire a novel sensorimotor skill. Using a virtual setup, subjects threw a virtual ball tethered to a post to hit a virtual target. Multiple combinations of release angle and velocity of the arm at ball release could achieve a target hit-the task was redundant and afforded solutions with different sensitivity to variability. Subjects performed 200 trials for two target locations that presented different types of redundancy. We hypothesized that children with dystonia develop strategies that are tolerant to their high variability. Estimating this variability highlighted the insufficiency of traditional outcome measures. Therefore, additional analyses of data distributions and of ball release timing were applied. Results showed that: 1) children with dystonia reduced their performance error despite their high variability; 2) this improvement was brought about by finding error-tolerant solutions; and 3) they generated arm trajectories that created time windows for ball release that were tolerant to timing variability. While reduced in magnitude, the performance improvements in children with dystonia paralleled those in healthy children and adults. These findings demonstrate that children with dystonia are able to adapt their behavior to their high variability, an important basis for any rehabilitative intervention.
患有肌张力障碍的儿童具有高度可变且看似不受控制的运动特征。对于任何康复努力而言,一个重要的问题是这些儿童是否能够学习并改善他们的表现。本研究比较了因脑瘫导致肌张力障碍的儿童、发育正常的儿童以及健康成年人获取一种新的感觉运动技能的能力。使用虚拟装置,受试者投掷一个系在柱子上的虚拟球以击中虚拟目标。在球释放时手臂的释放角度和速度的多种组合都可以实现目标击中——该任务具有冗余性,并且提供了对变异性具有不同敏感性的解决方案。受试者针对呈现不同类型冗余性的两个目标位置进行了200次试验。我们假设患有肌张力障碍的儿童会制定出能够容忍其高变异性的策略。对这种变异性的估计凸显了传统结果测量方法的不足。因此,我们对数据分布和球释放时间进行了额外分析。结果表明:1)患有肌张力障碍的儿童尽管变异性高,但仍降低了他们的表现误差;2)这种改善是通过找到容错解决方案实现的;3)他们生成的手臂轨迹为球释放创造了对时间变异性具有容忍度的时间窗口。虽然幅度有所降低,但患有肌张力障碍的儿童的表现改善与健康儿童和成年人的表现改善相似。这些发现表明,患有肌张力障碍的儿童能够使其行为适应其高变异性,这是任何康复干预的重要基础。