Michelson Kenneth A, Monuteaux Michael C, Neuman Mark I
Division of Emergency Medicine, Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, MA.
Acad Emerg Med. 2016 May;23(5):623-7. doi: 10.1111/acem.12922. Epub 2016 Apr 13.
We sought to determine the extent of variation in treatment of children with anaphylaxis.
We identified children 1 month to 18 years of age presenting with a primary diagnosis of anaphylaxis to one of the 35 pediatric hospitals included in the Pediatric Health Information System between January 1, 2009, and September 30, 2013. We evaluated the variation in use of β2 agonists, glucocorticoids, histamine-1 (H1) antagonists, histamine-2 (H2) antagonists, inhaled epinephrine, intravenous fluids, and oxygen. We assessed whether variation exists in the rates of hospitalization and 3-day emergency department (ED) revisits and whether a temporal trend exists in the ED visit rate for anaphylaxis.
Among 10,351 children with anaphylaxis, the hospital-level median use of common anaphylaxis therapies varied for β2 agonists (22%, interquartile range [IQR] = 16%-26%), glucocorticoids (71%, IQR = 65%-76%), H1 blockers (60%, IQR = 57%-65%), H2 blockers (53%, IQR = 36%-64%), inhaled epinephrine (2.2%, IQR = 1.3%-3.5%), intravenous fluids (26%, IQR = 13%-41%), and oxygen (2.6%, IQR = 0.8%-4.1%). Hospitalization rates ranged from 12% to 95%, with a median rate of 41%. Anaphylaxis diagnoses rose from 5.7 to 11.7 patients per 10,000 ED visits between 2009 and 2013 (p < 0.001 for trend).
There is substantial variability in the use of common therapies and hospitalization rates for children cared for in U.S. children's hospitals. Additionally, ED visits for children with anaphylaxis are increasing at U.S. children's hospitals. These findings highlight the need for research defining optimal care for anaphylaxis.
我们试图确定过敏反应患儿治疗的差异程度。
我们确定了2009年1月1日至2013年9月30日期间在儿科健康信息系统收录的35家儿科医院中,以过敏反应作为初步诊断的1个月至18岁儿童。我们评估了β2激动剂、糖皮质激素、组胺-1(H1)拮抗剂、组胺-2(H2)拮抗剂、吸入性肾上腺素、静脉输液和氧气使用情况的差异。我们评估了住院率和3天内急诊科复诊率是否存在差异,以及过敏反应的急诊科就诊率是否存在时间趋势。
在10351例过敏反应患儿中,各医院常用过敏反应治疗方法的使用中位数存在差异,β2激动剂为22%(四分位间距[IQR]=16%-26%),糖皮质激素为71%(IQR=65%-76%),H1阻滞剂为60%(IQR=57%-65%),H2阻滞剂为53%(IQR=36%-64%),吸入性肾上腺素为2.2%(IQR=1.3%-3.5%),静脉输液为26%(IQR=13%-41%),氧气为2.6%(IQR=0.8%-4.1%)。住院率从12%到95%不等,中位数为41%。2009年至2013年期间,每10000次急诊科就诊中过敏反应诊断病例从5.7例增至11.7例(趋势p<0.001)。
在美国儿童医院接受治疗的儿童中,常用治疗方法和住院率存在很大差异。此外,美国儿童医院中过敏反应患儿的急诊科就诊人数正在增加。这些发现凸显了开展研究以确定过敏反应最佳治疗方案的必要性。