Coleman Clifford A, Peterson-Perry Sylvia, Bumsted Tracy
Department of Family Medicine, Oregon Health & Science University.
Fam Med. 2016 Jan;48(1):49-53.
Although there are reports of short-term benefits of health literacy curricula for improving health care professionals' communication with patients, no studies have included long-term follow-up. We sought to determine (1) whether a pre-clerkship health literacy training can improve medical students' perceived knowledge and intended behaviors vis-á-vis communication with patients who have low health literacy, (2) the longevity of any such impact at 12 months, and (3) the impact of a follow-up training 1 year later.
We conducted pre- and post-training assessments of self-perceived knowledge and perceived and planned behavior following a health literacy training for first-year medical students, with a 12-month follow-up training and repeat pre/post assessment.
Among 48 pre-clerkship students, improvement was reported on 10 of 12 items following the Year 1 training. At 12-month follow-up, prior to the Year 2 training, ratings on 8 of 10 items had regressed to baseline levels. Nine of these items again improved significantly after the Year 2 training. Students were asked after both trainings if they felt they had overestimated their understanding of health literacy; significantly more students agreed with this statement following the Year 2 training than the Year 1 training.
Among a cohort of pre-clerkship medical students, improvements in perceived knowledge and planned behavior vis-á-vis health literacy training largely did not persist at 12-month follow-up. Efforts to teach medical students about health literacy principles and practices should include a longitudinal or integrated format, rather than a one-time lecture format.
尽管有报告称健康素养课程在改善医护人员与患者沟通方面有短期益处,但尚无研究进行长期随访。我们试图确定:(1)临床实习前的健康素养培训能否提高医学生对与健康素养低的患者沟通的认知知识和预期行为;(2)这种影响在12个月时的持续性;(3)1年后的后续培训的影响。
我们对一年级医学生进行健康素养培训前后的自我认知知识、感知行为和计划行为进行了评估,并进行了12个月的后续培训及重复的培训前/后评估。
在48名临床实习前的学生中,一年级培训后12项中的10项有改善。在12个月随访时,即二年级培训前,10项中的8项评分已回归到基线水平。二年级培训后,其中9项再次显著改善。两次培训后都询问学生是否觉得自己高估了对健康素养的理解;与一年级培训后相比,二年级培训后有更多学生认同这一说法。
在一群临床实习前的医学生中,健康素养培训后感知知识和计划行为的改善在12个月随访时大多没有持续。向医学生传授健康素养原则和实践的努力应采用纵向或综合形式,而非一次性讲座形式。