McAleese Sara, Clyne Barbara, Matthews Anne, Brugha Ruairí, Humphries Niamh
Department of Epidemiology and Public Health Medicine, Royal College of Surgeons, Dublin, Ireland.
Department of General Practice, Royal College of Surgeons, Dublin, Ireland.
Hum Resour Health. 2016 Jun 30;14(Suppl 1):34. doi: 10.1186/s12960-016-0130-y.
Health professionals, particularly doctors, nurses and midwives, are in high demand worldwide. Therefore, it is important to assess the future plans and likelihood of return of emigrating health professionals. Nevertheless, health professionals are, by definition, a difficult population to track/survey. This exploratory study reports on the migration intentions of a sample of doctors, nurses and midwives who had emigrated from Ireland, a high-income country which has experienced particularly high outward and inward migration of health professionals since the year 2000.
Health professionals who had emigrated from Ireland were identified via snowball sampling through Facebook and invited to complete a short online survey composed of closed and open response questions.
A total of 388 health professionals (307 doctors, 73 nurses and 8 midwives) who had previously worked in Ireland completed the survey. While over half had originally intended to spend less than 5 years in their destination country at the time of emigration, these intentions changed over time, with the desire to remain abroad on a permanent basis increasing from 10 to 34 % of doctor respondents. Only a quarter of doctors and a half of nurses and midwives intended to return to practice in Ireland in the future.
The longer health professionals remain abroad, the less likely they are to return to their home countries. Countries should focus on the implementation of retention strategies if the 'carousel' of brain drain is to be interrupted. This would allow source countries to benefit from their investments in training health professionals, rather than relying on international recruitment to meet health system staffing needs. Improved data collection systems are also needed to track the migratory patterns and changing intentions of health professionals. Meanwhile, social networking platforms offer alternative methods of filling this information gap.
全球对卫生专业人员,尤其是医生、护士和助产士的需求很高。因此,评估移民卫生专业人员的未来计划和回国可能性非常重要。然而,从定义上讲,卫生专业人员是难以追踪/调查的人群。这项探索性研究报告了一组从爱尔兰移民的医生、护士和助产士的移民意向,爱尔兰是一个高收入国家,自2000年以来经历了卫生专业人员的大量外流和内流。
通过在脸书上进行滚雪球抽样,确定从爱尔兰移民的卫生专业人员,并邀请他们完成一份简短的在线调查问卷,该问卷由封闭式和开放式问题组成。
共有388名曾在爱尔兰工作过的卫生专业人员(307名医生、73名护士和8名助产士)完成了调查。虽然超过一半的人在移民时最初打算在目的地国停留不到5年,但这些意向随时间发生了变化,打算永久留在国外的医生受访者比例从10%增加到了34%。只有四分之一的医生以及一半的护士和助产士打算未来回国执业。
卫生专业人员在国外停留的时间越长,回国的可能性就越小。如果要打断人才外流的“循环”,各国应专注于实施留住人才的策略。这将使来源国能够从其在培训卫生专业人员方面的投资中受益,而不是依赖国际招聘来满足卫生系统的人员配备需求。还需要改进数据收集系统,以追踪卫生专业人员的迁移模式和不断变化的意向。同时,社交网络平台提供了填补这一信息空白的替代方法。