Gatesoupe François-Joël, Huelvan Christine, Le Bayon Nicolas, Le Delliou Hervé, Madec Lauriane, Mouchel Olivier, Quazuguel Patrick, Mazurais David, Zambonino-Infante José-Luis
NUMEA, INRA, Univ. Pau & Pays Adour, 64310, Saint Pée sur Nivelle, France.
PFOM/ARN, Ifremer, Centre de Bretagne, CS 10070, 29280, Plouzané, France.
BMC Microbiol. 2016 Nov 8;16(1):266. doi: 10.1186/s12866-016-0885-2.
The better understanding of how intestinal microbiota interacts with fish health is one of the key to sustainable aquaculture development. The present experiment aimed at correlating active microbiota associated to intestinal mucosa with Specific Growth Rate (SGR) and Hypoxia Resistance Time (HRT) in European sea bass individuals submitted to different nutritional histories: the fish were fed either standard or unbalanced diets at first feeding, and then mixed before repeating the dietary challenge in a common garden approach at the juvenile stage.
A diet deficient in essential fatty acids (LH) lowered both SGR and HRT in sea bass, especially when the deficiency was already applied at first feeding. A protein-deficient diet with high starch supply (HG) reduced SGR to a lesser extent than LH, but it did not affect HRT. In overall average, 94 % of pyrosequencing reads corresponded to Proteobacteria, and the differences in Operational Taxonomy Units (OTUs) composition were mildly significant between experimental groups, mainly due to high individual variability. The highest and the lowest Bray-Curtis indices of intra-group similarity were observed in the two groups fed standard starter diet, and then mixed before the final dietary challenge with fish already exposed to the nutritional deficiency at first feeding (0.60 and 0.42 with diets HG and LH, respectively). Most noticeably, the median percentage of Escherichia-Shigella OTU_1 was less in the group LH with standard starter diet. Disregarding the nutritional history of each individual, strong correlation appeared between (1) OTU richness and SGR, and (2) dominance index and HRT. The two physiological traits correlated also with the relative abundance of distinct OTUs (positive correlations: Pseudomonas sp. OTU_3 and Herbaspirillum sp. OTU_10 with SGR, Paracoccus sp. OTU_4 and Vibrio sp. OTU_7 with HRT; negative correlation: Rhizobium sp. OTU_9 with HRT).
In sea bass, gut microbiota characteristics and physiological traits of individuals are linked together, interfering with nutritional history, and resulting in high variability among individual microbiota. Many samples and tank replicates seem necessary to further investigate the effect of experimental treatments on gut microbiota composition, and to test the hypothesis whether microbiotypes may be delineated in fish.
更好地理解肠道微生物群如何与鱼类健康相互作用是可持续水产养殖发展的关键之一。本实验旨在将与肠道黏膜相关的活跃微生物群与欧洲海鲈个体的特定生长率(SGR)和耐缺氧时间(HRT)相关联,这些个体具有不同的营养史:在初次投喂时,鱼被喂食标准或不均衡的饲料,然后混合,之后在幼鱼阶段采用共同养殖方式重复饮食挑战。
缺乏必需脂肪酸的饮食(LH)降低了海鲈的SGR和HRT,尤其是在初次投喂时就出现这种缺乏情况时。高淀粉供应的蛋白质缺乏饮食(HG)对SGR的降低程度小于LH,但不影响HRT。总体平均而言,94%的焦磷酸测序读数对应于变形菌门,实验分组间的操作分类单元(OTU)组成差异不显著,主要是由于个体差异较大。在两组投喂标准起始饲料、然后混合、最后进行饮食挑战的鱼中,观察到组内相似性的最高和最低Bray-Curtis指数,其中一组鱼在初次投喂时已暴露于营养缺乏状态(HG和LH饮食组分别为0.60和0.42)。最值得注意的是,在LH组中,使用标准起始饲料时,埃希氏菌-志贺氏菌OTU_1的中位数百分比更低。不考虑每个个体的营养史,(1)OTU丰富度与SGR之间以及(2)优势度指数与HRT之间存在强相关性。这两个生理特征也与不同OTU的相对丰度相关(正相关:假单胞菌属OTU_3和草螺菌属OTU_10与SGR,副球菌属OTU_4和弧菌属OTU_7与HRT;负相关:根瘤菌属OTU_9与HRT)。
在海鲈中,个体的肠道微生物群特征和生理特征相互关联,受营养史影响,导致个体微生物群差异较大。似乎需要许多样本和养殖池重复实验,以进一步研究实验处理对肠道微生物群组成的影响,并检验是否可以在鱼类中划分微生物型的假设。