Grooten Wilhelmus Johannes Andreas, Müller Mira, Forsman Mikael, Kjellberg Katarina, Toomingas Allan, Björn Olov Ång, Svartengren Magnus
Department of Neurobiology, Care Sciences and Society, Division of Physical Therapy, Karolinska Institutet, Sweden.
Functional Area Occupational Therapy & Physiotherapy, Allied Health Professionals Function, Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden.
Work. 2016;55(4):849-859. doi: 10.3233/WOR-162443.
Health risk appraisals (HRAs) in occupational health services (OHS) in Sweden are very commonly used for health promotion issues, but not much research has explored the extent and nature of individual feedback that is provided.
This study aimed to describe and explore HRAs in OHS regarding the content of the feedback in relation to the individual status and overall employee satisfaction.
Feedback (evaluation and advice) and employee satisfaction with HRA were studied in employees that participated in health risk appraisals with a specific feedback session (HRA-F) (n = 272) and employees that participated in a single session (HRA-S) (n = 104). Associations between feedback and individual status concerning life style were assessed with Cohen's kappa (k).
The employees received mainly information and advice for improvement on health and lifestyle issues (89-100%), while advice for improvement of working conditions was less common (15-59%). The feedback provided on life style was not based on individual status (k < 0.4), except for smoking and risky alcohol consumption (k > 0.55). A great majority of employees reported good overall satisfaction with their HRAs.
The evaluation and feedback given to employees after HRAs should be based more on HRA-results and advice could be focused more on work-related factors.
在瑞典,职业健康服务(OHS)中的健康风险评估(HRA)被广泛用于健康促进问题,但对于所提供的个体反馈的范围和性质,尚未有太多研究。
本研究旨在描述和探讨职业健康服务中的健康风险评估,涉及与个体状况相关的反馈内容以及员工总体满意度。
对参加了有特定反馈环节的健康风险评估(HRA-F)的员工(n = 272)和参加单次评估的员工(HRA-S)(n = 104)的反馈(评估和建议)以及员工对HRA的满意度进行了研究。使用科恩kappa系数(k)评估反馈与生活方式个体状况之间的关联。
员工主要收到关于健康和生活方式问题改善的信息和建议(89%-100%),而关于改善工作条件的建议则较少见(15%-59%)。除吸烟和危险饮酒外,关于生活方式的反馈并非基于个体状况(k < 0.4),吸烟和危险饮酒方面的反馈(k > 0.55)。绝大多数员工对他们的健康风险评估总体满意度较高。
健康风险评估后给予员工的评估和反馈应更多地基于HRA结果,建议可更多地侧重于与工作相关的因素。