Kockelkoren Remko, Vos Annelotte, Van Hecke Wim, Vink Aryan, Bleys Ronald L A W, Verdoorn Daphne, Mali Willem P Th M, Hendrikse Jeroen, Koek Huiberdina L, de Jong Pim A, De Vis Jill B
Department of Radiology, University Medical Center, Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Department of Pathology, University Medical Center, Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
PLoS One. 2017 Jan 6;12(1):e0168360. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0168360. eCollection 2017.
Intracranial internal carotid artery (iICA) calcification is associated with stroke and is often seen as a proxy of atherosclerosis of the intima. However, it was recently shown that these calcifications are predominantly located in the tunica media and internal elastic lamina (medial calcification). Intimal and medial calcifications are thought to have a different pathogenesis and clinical consequences and can only be distinguished through ex vivo histological analysis. Therefore, our aim was to develop CT scoring method to distinguish intimal and medial iICA calcification in vivo.
First, in both iICAs of 16 cerebral autopsy patients the intimal and/or medial calcification area was histologically assessed (142 slides). Brain CT images of these patients were matched to the corresponding histological slides to develop a CT score that determines intimal or medial calcification dominance. Second, performance of the CT score was assessed in these 16 patients. Third, reproducibility was tested in a separate cohort.
First, CT features of the score were circularity (absent, dot(s), <90°, 90-270° or 270-360°), thickness (absent, ≥1.5mm, or <1.5mm), and morphology (indistinguishable, irregular/patchy or continuous). A high sum of features represented medial and a lower sum intimal calcifications. Second, in the 16 patients the concordance between the CT score and the dominant calcification type was reasonable. Third, the score showed good reproducibility (kappa: 0.72 proportion of agreement: 0.82) between the categories intimal, medial or absent/indistinguishable.
The developed CT score shows good reproducibility and can differentiate reasonably well between intimal and medial calcification dominance in the iICA, allowing for further (epidemiological) studies on iICA calcification.
颅内颈内动脉(iICA)钙化与中风相关,常被视为内膜动脉粥样硬化的替代指标。然而,最近研究表明,这些钙化主要位于中膜和内弹性膜(中膜钙化)。内膜钙化和中膜钙化被认为具有不同的发病机制和临床后果,且只能通过离体组织学分析加以区分。因此,我们的目的是开发一种CT评分方法,以在体内区分iICA的内膜钙化和中膜钙化。
首先,对16例脑尸检患者的双侧iICA内膜和/或中膜钙化区域进行组织学评估(142张切片)。将这些患者的脑部CT图像与相应的组织学切片进行匹配,以制定一个CT评分,用于确定内膜或中膜钙化的优势情况。其次,对这16例患者的CT评分性能进行评估。第三,在一个单独的队列中测试其可重复性。
首先,该评分的CT特征包括圆形度(无、点状、<90°、90 - 270°或270 - 360°)、厚度(无、≥1.5mm或<1.5mm)和形态(无法区分、不规则/斑片状或连续)。特征总和较高代表中膜钙化,较低则代表内膜钙化。其次,在这16例患者中,CT评分与主要钙化类型之间的一致性较为合理。第三,该评分在内膜、中膜或无/无法区分类别之间显示出良好的可重复性(kappa值:0.72,一致性比例:0.82)。
所开发的CT评分显示出良好的可重复性,能够较好地区分iICA内膜钙化和中膜钙化的优势情况,有助于对iICA钙化进行进一步的(流行病学)研究。