Sprague Martinez Linda, Reisner Ellin, Campbell Maria, Brugge Doug
Macro Department, Boston University School of Social Work, 264 Bay State Road, Boston, MA 02215, USA.
Somerville Transportation Equity Partnership, 51 Mt. Vernon Street, Somerville, MA 02145, USA.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2017 Feb 4;14(2):149. doi: 10.3390/ijerph14020149.
Conflicting interests, power imbalance and relationships characterized by distrust are just a few of the many challenges community-academic research partnerships face. In addition, the time it takes to build relationships is often overlooked, which further complicates matters and can leave well-intentioned individuals re-creating oppressive conditions through inauthentic partnerships. This paper presents a novel approach of using meeting minutes to explore partnership dynamics. The Community Assessment of Freeway Exposure and Health (CAFEH) partnership is used as an illustrative case study to identify how community academic partnerships overcome the challenges associated with community-based participatory research (CBPR). CAFEH is a study of ultrafine particle exposure (UFP) near highways in the Boston, MA area. Qualitative analysis was applied to meeting minutes and process evaluation reports from the first three years of the CAFEH study ( = 73 files). In addition, a group meeting was held with project partners in order to contextualize the findings from the document analysis. The three most commonly referenced challenges included language barriers, the overall project structure and budgetary constraints. Meanwhile, a heavy emphasis on process and an approach steeped in participatory democracy facilitated CAFEH's ability to overcome these challenges, as well as sustain and augment strong partnership ties. This experience suggests that leadership that incorporates an organizing approach and a transformational style facilitates CBPR processes and helps teams surmount challenges.
利益冲突、权力失衡以及以不信任为特征的关系,只是社区 - 学术研究伙伴关系面临的众多挑战中的一部分。此外,建立关系所需的时间常常被忽视,这使得情况更加复杂,可能导致善意的个人通过不真实的伙伴关系重新制造压迫性的状况。本文提出了一种利用会议记录来探索伙伴关系动态的新方法。高速公路暴露与健康社区评估(CAFEH)伙伴关系被用作一个说明性案例研究,以确定社区学术伙伴关系如何克服与社区参与式研究(CBPR)相关的挑战。CAFEH是一项关于马萨诸塞州波士顿地区高速公路附近超细颗粒物暴露(UFP)的研究。对CAFEH研究头三年的会议记录和过程评估报告(共73份文件)进行了定性分析。此外,还与项目伙伴举行了一次小组会议,以便将文件分析的结果置于具体情境中。三个最常被提及的挑战包括语言障碍、总体项目结构和预算限制。与此同时,对过程的高度重视以及一种植根于参与式民主的方法促进了CAFEH克服这些挑战的能力,以及维持和加强牢固的伙伴关系。这一经验表明,采用组织方法和变革型风格的领导力有助于CBPR过程,并帮助团队克服挑战。