Amoah Isaac Dennis, Singh Gulshan, Stenström Thor Axel, Reddy Poovendhree
Institute for Water and Wastewater Technology (IWWT), Durban University of Technology, PO Box 1334, Durban, 4000, South Africa; Department of Community Health Studies, Faculty of Health Sciences Durban University of Technology, PO Box 1334, Durban, 4000, South Africa.
Institute for Water and Wastewater Technology (IWWT), Durban University of Technology, PO Box 1334, Durban, 4000, South Africa.
Acta Trop. 2017 May;169:187-201. doi: 10.1016/j.actatropica.2017.02.014. Epub 2017 Feb 15.
It is estimated that over a billion people are infected with soil-transmitted helminths (STHs) globally with majority occurring in tropical and subtropical regions of the world. The roundworm (Ascaris lumbricoides), whipworm (Trichuris trichiura), and hookworms (Ancylostoma duodenale and Necator americanus) are the main species infecting people. These infections are mostly gained through exposure to faecally contaminated water, soil or contaminated food and with an increase in the risk of infections due to wastewater and sludge reuse in agriculture. Different methods have been developed for the detection and quantification of STHs eggs in environmental samples. However, there is a lack of a universally accepted technique which creates a challenge for comparative assessments of helminths egg concentrations both in different samples matrices as well as between locations. This review presents a comparison of reported methodologies for the detection of STHs eggs, an assessment of the relative performance of available detection methods and a discussion of new emerging techniques that could be applied for detection and quantification. It is based on a literature search using PubMed and Science Direct considering all geographical locations. Original research articles were selected based on their methodology and results sections. Methods reported in these articles were grouped into conventional, molecular and emerging techniques, the main steps in each method were then compared and discussed. The inclusion of a dissociation step aimed at detaching helminth eggs from particulate matter was found to improve the recovery of eggs. Additionally the selection and application of flotation solutions that take into account the relative densities of the eggs of different species of STHs also results in higher egg recovery. Generally the use of conventional methods was shown to be laborious and time consuming and prone to human error. The alternate use of nucleic acid-based techniques has improved the sensitivity of detection and made species specific identification possible. However, these nucleic acid based methods are expensive and less suitable in regions with limited resources and skill. The loop mediated isothermal amplification method shows promise for application in these settings due to its simplicity and use of basic equipment. In addition, the development of imaging soft-ware for the detection and quantification of STHs shows promise to further reduce human error associated with the analysis of environmental samples. It may be concluded that there is a need to comparatively assess the performance of different methods to determine their applicability in different settings as well as for use with different sample matrices (wastewater, sludge, compost, soil, vegetables etc.).
据估计,全球有超过10亿人感染土源性蠕虫(STHs),其中大多数发生在世界热带和亚热带地区。蛔虫(似蚓蛔线虫)、鞭虫(三毛鞭虫)和钩虫(十二指肠钩口线虫和美洲板口线虫)是感染人类的主要种类。这些感染大多是通过接触受粪便污染的水、土壤或受污染的食物而获得的,并且由于农业中废水和污泥的再利用,感染风险增加。已经开发出不同的方法来检测和定量环境样品中的土源性蠕虫虫卵。然而,缺乏一种普遍接受的技术,这给不同样品基质以及不同地点之间的蠕虫虫卵浓度的比较评估带来了挑战。本综述对已报道的检测土源性蠕虫虫卵的方法进行了比较,评估了现有检测方法的相对性能,并讨论了可用于检测和定量的新兴技术。它基于使用PubMed和ScienceDirect进行的文献检索,涵盖所有地理位置。根据其方法和结果部分选择了原始研究文章。这些文章中报道的方法分为传统方法、分子方法和新兴技术,然后对每种方法的主要步骤进行了比较和讨论。发现加入旨在将蠕虫虫卵与颗粒物分离的解离步骤可提高虫卵回收率。此外,选择和应用考虑到不同种类土源性蠕虫虫卵相对密度的浮选溶液也会提高虫卵回收率。一般来说,传统方法的使用被证明既费力又耗时,而且容易出现人为误差。基于核酸的技术的交替使用提高了检测的灵敏度,并使物种特异性鉴定成为可能。然而,这些基于核酸的方法成本高昂,在资源和技术有限的地区不太适用。环介导等温扩增法因其简单性和对基本设备的使用,在这些环境中显示出应用前景。此外,用于检测和定量土源性蠕虫的成像软件的开发有望进一步减少与环境样品分析相关的人为误差。可以得出结论,需要对不同方法的性能进行比较评估,以确定它们在不同环境以及与不同样品基质(废水、污泥、堆肥、土壤、蔬菜等)一起使用时的适用性。