Oakley Catherine
Med Humanit. 2018 Mar;44(1):5-14. doi: 10.1136/medhum-2017-011209. Epub 2017 May 11.
This paper argues for an approach within the medical humanities that draws on the theoretical legacy of cultural materialism as a framework for reading cultural practices and their relationship to the social and economic order. It revisits the origins and development of cultural materialism in cultural studies and literary studies between the 1970s and 1990s and considers how, with adaptation, this methodology might facilitate ideological criticism focused on material formations of health, disease and the human body. I outline three key characteristics of a medicocultural materialist approach along these lines: (a) interdisciplinary work on a broad range of medical and cultural sources, including those drawn from 'popular' forms of culture; (b) the combination of historicist analysis with scrutiny of present-day contexts; (c) analyses that engage with political economy perspectives and/or the work of medical sociology in this area. The subsequent sections of the paper employ a medicocultural materialist approach to examine conjectural understandings of, and empirical investigations into, the capacity of transfused human blood to rejuvenate the ageing body. I trace textual faultlines that expose the structures of power which inform the movement of blood between bodies in 'medical gothic' fictions from the 19th-century fin de siècle, including Mary Elizabeth Braddon's 'Good Lady Ducayne' (1896) and Bram Stoker's (1897). I conclude with a critique of biomedical innovations in blood rejuvenation in the era of medical neoliberalism, before considering the potential applications of medicocultural materialism to other topics within the field of the medical humanities.
本文主张在医学人文学科中采用一种方法,该方法借鉴文化唯物主义的理论遗产,作为解读文化实践及其与社会经济秩序关系的框架。它回顾了20世纪70年代至90年代文化研究和文学研究中文化唯物主义的起源与发展,并思考经过调整后,这种方法如何促进聚焦于健康、疾病和人体物质形态的意识形态批判。我按照这些思路概述了医学文化唯物主义方法的三个关键特征:(a)对广泛的医学和文化来源进行跨学科研究,包括那些源自“大众”文化形式的来源;(b)将历史主义分析与对当今背景的审视相结合;(c)与政治经济学视角和/或该领域医学社会学著作相结合的分析。本文随后的章节采用医学文化唯物主义方法,审视关于输注人血使衰老身体恢复活力的推测性理解以及实证研究。我追溯文本中的断层线,这些断层线揭示了权力结构,这些结构影响着19世纪末“医学哥特式”小说中身体间血液流动的情况,包括玛丽·伊丽莎白·布拉登的《杜凯夫人》(1896年)和布拉姆·斯托克的《德古拉》(1897年)。在考虑医学文化唯物主义在医学人文学科领域其他主题的潜在应用之前,我对医学新自由主义时代血液恢复活力方面的生物医学创新进行了批判。