Burton Elissa, Farrier Kaela, Hill Keith D, Codde Jim, Airey Phil, Hill Anne-Marie
a Institute for Health Research , The University of Notre Dame Australia , Fremantle , Western Australia , Australia.
b School of Physiotherapy and Exercise Science , Curtin University , Perth , Western Australia , Australia.
J Sports Sci. 2018 Mar;36(6):666-678. doi: 10.1080/02640414.2017.1329549. Epub 2017 May 23.
The objective of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to evaluate the effectiveness of peers to deliver programs or encourage older people to be physically active and improve physical outcomes. Peer reviewed articles published in English between January 1976 and June 2016, retrieved from six databases according to the predefined inclusion criteria were included. Where possible results were pooled and meta-analyses conducted. Eighteen articles were included in the review, a total of 3,492 intervention participants, average age 66.5 years and 67.1% were female. Overall, study quality was medium to high. Interventions mainly included resistance, flexibility and cardiovascular training, however there was one aquatic exercise group. Eight studies were delivered by peers and five utilised peer support, which included advice and being positive but was not directly linked to an exercise intervention. While 16 of the 18 studies reported improvement in levels of physical activity and/or noted physical benefits by peer involvement, the meta-analyses findings supported the control groups for the six-minute-walk-test and the timed-up-and-go test. Findings from this review suggest exercise programs involving peers can promote and maintain adherence to exercise programs. However, results were inconclusive as to whether peers have a positive effect on improving older people's physical function.
本系统评价和荟萃分析的目的是评估同伴实施项目或鼓励老年人进行体育活动并改善身体状况的有效性。纳入了根据预定义的纳入标准从六个数据库中检索到的1976年1月至2016年6月期间以英文发表的同行评审文章。在可能的情况下,对结果进行汇总并进行荟萃分析。该评价纳入了18篇文章,共有3492名干预参与者,平均年龄66.5岁,67.1%为女性。总体而言,研究质量为中等至高。干预措施主要包括阻力训练、柔韧性训练和心血管训练,但有一个水上运动组。八项研究由同伴实施,五项研究利用了同伴支持,其中包括建议和给予积极态度,但与运动干预没有直接联系。虽然18项研究中的16项报告称,通过同伴参与,身体活动水平有所提高和/或注意到了身体方面的益处,但荟萃分析结果支持对照组在六分钟步行试验和计时起立行走试验中的表现。该评价的结果表明,涉及同伴的运动项目可以促进和维持对运动项目的依从性。然而,关于同伴是否对改善老年人身体功能有积极影响,结果尚无定论。