Schildmann Jan, Bruns Florian, Hess Volker, Vollmann Jochen
Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Institut für Medizinische Ethik und Geschichte der Medizin, Bochum, Germany.
Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Institut für Geschichte der Medizin und Ethik in der Medizin, Berlin Germany.
GMS J Med Educ. 2017 May 15;34(2):Doc23. doi: 10.3205/zma001100. eCollection 2017.
"History, Theory, Ethics of Medicine" (German: "Geschichte, Theorie, Ethik der Medizin", abbreviation: GTE) forms part of the obligatory curriculum for medical students in Germany since the winter semester 2003/2004. This paper presents the results of a national survey on the contents, methods and framework of GTE teaching. Semi-structured questionnaire dispatched in July 2014 to 38 institutions responsible for GTE teaching. Descriptive analysis of quantitative data and content analysis of free-text answers. It was possible to collect data from 29 institutes responsible for GTE teaching (response: 76%). There is at least one professorial chair for GTE in 19 faculties; two professorial chairs or professorships remained vacant at the time of the survey. The number of students taught per academic year ranges from <100 to >350. Teaching in GTE comprises an average of 2.18 hours per week per semester (min: 1, max: 6). Teaching in GTE is proportionally distributed according to an arithmetic average as follows: history: 35.4%, theory 14.7% and ethics 49.9%. Written learning objectives were formulated for GTE in 24 faculties. The preferred themes of teaching in history, theory or ethics which according to respondents should be taught comprise a broad spectrum and vary. Teaching in ethics (79 from a max. of 81 possible points) is, when compared to history (61/81) and theory (53/81), attributed the most significance for the training of medical doctors. 10 years after the introduction of GTE the number of students and the personnel resources available at the institutions vary considerably. In light of the differences regarding the content elicited in this study the pros and cons of heterogeneity in GTE should be discussed.
《医学史、理论与伦理学》(德语:《Geschichte, Theorie, Ethik der Medizin》,缩写:GTE)自2003/2004年冬季学期起成为德国医科学生必修课程的一部分。本文展示了一项关于GTE教学内容、方法和框架的全国性调查结果。2014年7月向38个负责GTE教学的机构发放了半结构化问卷。对定量数据进行描述性分析,并对自由文本答案进行内容分析。共收集到29个负责GTE教学的机构的数据(回复率:76%)。19个学院至少设有一个GTE教授职位;调查时,有两个教授职位空缺。每学年授课的学生人数从不足100人到超过350人不等。GTE教学每学期平均每周2.18小时(最少1小时,最多6小时)。GTE教学按算术平均数成比例分布如下:历史:35.4%,理论14.7%,伦理学49.9%。24个学院为GTE制定了书面学习目标。受访者认为应讲授的历史、理论或伦理学教学的首选主题范围广泛且各不相同。与历史(61/81)和理论(53/81)相比,伦理学教学(满分81分,得79分)被认为对医学生的培训最为重要。GTE引入10年后,各机构的学生人数和可用人力资源差异很大。鉴于本研究中所揭示的内容差异,应讨论GTE异质性的利弊。