Mahmood Hana, Suleman Yasmeen, Hazir Tabish, Akram Durre Samin, Uddin Shahadat, Dibley Michael J, Abassi Saleem, Shakeel Amara, Kazmi Narjis, Thow Anne Marie
Maternal, Neonatal and Child Health Research Network (MNCHRN)/ International Research Force (IRF), Islamabad, Pakistan.
Health, Education and Literacy Program (HELP), Karachi, Pakistan.
BMC Public Health. 2017 Jun 13;17(Suppl 2):474. doi: 10.1186/s12889-017-4341-5.
Appropriate infant and young child feeding (IYCF) practices have been identified as important for appropriate child growth and development. (Ministry of Planning and Development, Ministry of National Health Services, Regulations and Coordination (2012)) Children in Pakistan still experience high rates of malnutrition, indicating a likely need for stronger IYCF policy. The purpose of this study was to identify major stakeholders who shape the IYCF policy environment and analyze which policies protect, promote and support IYCF practices, either directly or indirectly.
This study was conducted at the federal level, and in the provinces of Sindh and Punjab. We identified policies relevant to IYCF using a matrix developed by the South Asian Infant Feeding Research Network (SAIFRN), designed to capture policies at a range of levels (strategic policy documents through to implementation guidelines) in sectors relevant to IYCF. We analyzed the content using predetermined themes focused on support for mothers, and used narrative synthesis to present our findings. For the stakeholder analysis, we conducted four Net-Map activities with 49 interviewees using the Net-Map methodology. We analyzed the quantitative data using Organizational Risk Analyzer ORA and used the qualitative data to elucidate further information regarding relationships between stakeholders.
We identified 19 policy documents for analysis. Eleven of these were nutrition and/or IYCF focused and eight were broader policies with IYCF as a component. The majority lacked detail relevant to implementation, particularly in terms of: ownership of the policies by a specific government body; sustainability of programs/strategies (most are donor funded), multi-sectoral collaboration; and effective advocacy and behavior change communication. Data collected through four Net-Map activities showed that after devolution of health ministry, provincial health departments were the key actors in the government whereas UNICEF and WHO were the key donors who were also highly influential and supportive of the objective.
This analysis identified opportunities to strengthen IYCF policy in Pakistan through increased clarity on roles and responsibilities, improved multisectoral collaboration, and strong and consistent training guidelines and schedules for community health workers. The current policy environment presents opportunities, despite limitations. Our Net-Map analysis indicated several key government and international stakeholders, who differed across Federal and Provincial study sites. The detailed information regarding stakeholder influence can be used to strengthen advocacy.
适当的婴幼儿喂养(IYCF)做法已被确定对儿童的适当生长和发育至关重要。(规划与发展部、国家卫生服务、法规与协调部(2012年))巴基斯坦儿童的营养不良率仍然很高,这表明可能需要更强有力的IYCF政策。本研究的目的是确定塑造IYCF政策环境的主要利益相关者,并分析哪些政策直接或间接地保护、促进和支持IYCF做法。
本研究在联邦层面以及信德省和旁遮普省进行。我们使用南亚婴幼儿喂养研究网络(SAIFRN)开发的矩阵来确定与IYCF相关的政策,该矩阵旨在收集IYCF相关部门一系列层面(从战略政策文件到实施指南)的政策。我们使用预先确定的、侧重于对母亲支持的主题来分析内容,并使用叙述性综合法来呈现我们的研究结果。对于利益相关者分析,我们使用网络映射方法与49名受访者进行了四项网络映射活动。我们使用组织风险分析器ORA分析定量数据,并使用定性数据来阐明有关利益相关者之间关系的更多信息。
我们确定了19份政策文件进行分析。其中11份以营养和/或IYCF为重点,8份是将IYCF作为一个组成部分的更广泛政策。大多数文件缺乏与实施相关的细节,特别是在以下方面:特定政府机构对政策的所有权;项目/战略的可持续性(大多数由捐助者资助)、多部门合作;以及有效的宣传和行为改变沟通。通过四项网络映射活动收集的数据表明,卫生部权力下放后,省级卫生部门是政府中的关键行为者,而联合国儿童基金会和世界卫生组织是关键捐助者,它们也对该目标具有高度影响力并提供支持。
本分析确定了通过明确角色和责任、改善多部门合作以及为社区卫生工作者制定强有力且一致的培训指南和时间表来加强巴基斯坦IYCF政策的机会。尽管存在局限性,但当前的政策环境仍提供了机会。我们的网络映射分析表明了几个关键的政府和国际利益相关者,他们在联邦和省级研究地点有所不同。有关利益相关者影响力的详细信息可用于加强宣传。