Department of Land Economy, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB3 9EP, United Kingdom;
Department of Pathology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 1QP, United Kingdom.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2017 Sep 5;114(36):E7425-E7431. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1700166114. Epub 2017 Jul 24.
Community health interventions often seek to intentionally destroy paths between individuals to prevent the spread of infectious diseases. Immunizing individuals through direct vaccination or the provision of health education prevents pathogen transmission and the propagation of misinformation concerning medical treatments. However, it remains an open question whether network-based strategies should be used in place of conventional field approaches to target individuals for medical treatment in low-income countries. We collected complete friendship and health advice networks in 17 rural villages of Mayuge District, Uganda. Here we show that acquaintance algorithms, i.e., selecting neighbors of randomly selected nodes, were systematically more efficient in fragmenting all networks than targeting well-established community roles, i.e., health workers, village government members, and schoolteachers. Additionally, community roles were not good proxy indicators of physical proximity to other households or connections to many sick people. We also show that acquaintance algorithms were effective in offsetting potential noncompliance with deworming treatments for 16,357 individuals during mass drug administration (MDA). Health advice networks were destroyed more easily than friendship networks. Only an average of 32% of nodes were removed from health advice networks to reduce the percentage of nodes at risk for refusing treatment in MDA to below 25%. Treatment compliance of at least 75% is needed in MDA to control human morbidity attributable to parasitic worms and progress toward elimination. Our findings point toward the potential use of network-based approaches as an alternative to role-based strategies for targeting individuals in rural health interventions.
社区卫生干预措施通常旨在有意破坏个体之间的联系,以防止传染病的传播。通过直接接种疫苗或提供健康教育来使个体免疫,可防止病原体传播和有关医疗处理的错误信息的传播。然而,在低收入国家,针对个体进行治疗的网络策略是否应替代传统的现场方法,这仍然是一个悬而未决的问题。我们在乌干达马尤盖区的 17 个农村村庄收集了完整的友谊和健康咨询网络。在这里,我们表明,相识算法(即随机选择节点的邻居)比针对既定的社区角色(即卫生工作者、村庄政府成员和教师)更系统地有效地分割所有网络。此外,社区角色并不能很好地代表与其他家庭的实际接近程度或与许多病人的联系。我们还表明,相识算法在大规模药物治疗(MDA)期间针对 16357 个人的驱虫治疗中有效减少了潜在的不依从性。健康咨询网络比友谊网络更容易被破坏。仅需从健康咨询网络中删除平均 32%的节点,即可将 MDA 中拒绝治疗的风险节点比例降低到 25%以下。MDA 中至少需要 75%的治疗依从性,才能控制寄生虫引起的人类发病率,并朝着消除寄生虫病的目标迈进。我们的研究结果表明,网络方法可能是针对农村卫生干预中个体的替代基于角色的策略。