Hu Chao S, Ferrari Michel, Wang Qiandong, Woodruff Earl
Institutes of Psychological Sciences, Hangzhou Normal UniversityHangzhou, China.
Centre for Cognition and Brain Disorders, Hangzhou Normal UniversityHangzhou, China.
Front Psychol. 2017 Aug 15;8:1378. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01378. eCollection 2017.
Objective Measurement of Wisdom within a short period of time is vital for both the public interest (e.g., understanding a presidential election) and research (e.g., testing factors that facilitate wisdom development). A measurement of emotion associated with wisdom would be especially informative; therefore, a novel Thin-Slice measurement of wisdom was developed based on the Berlin Paradigm. For about 2 min, participants imagined the lens of a camera as the eyes of their friend/teacher whom they advised about a life dilemma. Verbal response and facial expression were both recorded by a camera: verbal responses were then rated on both the Berlin Wisdom criteria and newly developed Chinese wisdom criteria; facial expressions were analyzed by the software iMotion FACET module. Results showed acceptable inter-rater and inter-item reliability for this novel paradigm. Moreover, both wisdom ratings were not significantly correlated with Social desirability, and the Berlin wisdom rating was significantly negatively correlated with Neuroticism; feeling of surprise was significantly positively correlated with both wisdom criteria ratings. Our results provide the first evidence of this Thin-slice Wisdom Paradigm's reliability, its immunity to social desirability, and its validity for assessing candidates' wisdom within a short timeframe. Although still awaiting further development, this novel Paradigm contributes to an emerging Universal Wisdom Paradigm applicable across cultures.
在短时间内客观测量智慧对于公共利益(例如,理解总统选举)和研究(例如,测试促进智慧发展的因素)都至关重要。对与智慧相关的情绪进行测量将特别有启发性;因此,基于柏林范式开发了一种新颖的智慧薄片测量方法。在大约2分钟的时间里,参与者将相机镜头想象成他们为生活困境提供建议的朋友/老师的眼睛。言语反应和面部表情都由相机记录:然后根据柏林智慧标准和新制定的中国智慧标准对言语反应进行评分;面部表情由iMotion FACET模块软件进行分析。结果表明,这种新颖的范式具有可接受的评分者间和项目间信度。此外,两种智慧评分与社会赞许性均无显著相关性,柏林智慧评分与神经质呈显著负相关;惊讶感与两种智慧标准评分均呈显著正相关。我们的结果首次证明了这种智慧薄片范式的可靠性、对社会赞许性的免疫性以及在短时间内评估候选人智慧的有效性。尽管仍有待进一步发展,但这种新颖的范式为一种新兴的适用于跨文化的通用智慧范式做出了贡献。