Lafita Aleix, Bliven Spencer, Kryshtafovych Andriy, Bertoni Martino, Monastyrskyy Bohdan, Duarte Jose M, Schwede Torsten, Capitani Guido
Laboratory of Biomolecular Research, Paul Scherrer Institute, Villigen, PSI, 5232, Switzerland.
Department of Biosystems Science and Engineering, ETH Zurich, Basel, 4058, Switzerland.
Proteins. 2018 Mar;86 Suppl 1(Suppl 1):247-256. doi: 10.1002/prot.25408. Epub 2017 Nov 8.
We present the results of the first independent assessment of protein assemblies in CASP. A total of 1624 oligomeric models were submitted by 108 predictor groups for the 30 oligomeric targets in the CASP12 edition. We evaluated the accuracy of oligomeric predictions by comparison to their reference structures at the interface patch and residue contact levels. We find that interface patches are more reliably predicted than the specific residue contacts. Whereas none of the 15 hard oligomeric targets have successful predictions for the residue contacts at the interface, six have models with resemblance in the interface patch. Successful predictions of interface patch and contacts exist for all targets suitable for homology modeling, with at least one group improving over the best available template for each target. However, the participation in protein assembly prediction is low and uneven. Three human groups are closely ranked at the top by overall performance, but a server outperforms all other predictors for targets suitable for homology modeling. The state of the art of protein assembly prediction methods is in development and has apparent room for improvement, especially for assemblies without templates.
我们展示了在蛋白质结构预测关键评估(CASP)中对蛋白质组装体进行的首次独立评估结果。在CASP12版本中,108个预测组针对30个寡聚体靶标总共提交了1624个寡聚体模型。我们通过在界面补丁和残基接触水平上与参考结构进行比较,评估了寡聚体预测的准确性。我们发现,界面补丁的预测比特定残基接触更可靠。虽然15个难的寡聚体靶标中没有一个在界面处的残基接触预测成功,但有6个靶标的模型在界面补丁上有相似之处。对于所有适合同源建模的靶标,都存在界面补丁和接触的成功预测,每个靶标至少有一个组比最佳可用模板有所改进。然而,参与蛋白质组装预测的情况较少且不均衡。三个团队在整体表现上排名靠前,但对于适合同源建模的靶标,一个服务器的表现优于所有其他预测器。蛋白质组装预测方法的技术水平仍在发展,并且有明显的改进空间,特别是对于没有模板的组装体。