Laboratory of Clinical Investigation, National Institute on Aging, National Institutes of Health, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
Magn Reson Med. 2018 Jun;79(6):3249-3255. doi: 10.1002/mrm.26984. Epub 2017 Nov 1.
The Cramér-Rao lower bound (CRLB) is widely used in the design of magnetic resonance (MR) experiments for parameter estimation. Previous work has considered only Gaussian or Rician noise distributions in this calculation. However, the noise distribution for multi-coil acquisitions, such as in parallel imaging, obeys the noncentral χ-distribution under many circumstances. The purpose of this paper is to present the CRLB calculation for parameter estimation from multi-coil acquisitions.
We perform explicit calculations of Fisher matrix elements and the associated CRLB for noise distributions following the noncentral χ-distribution. The special case of diffusion kurtosis is examined as an important example. For comparison with analytic results, Monte Carlo (MC) simulations were conducted to evaluate experimental minimum standard deviations (SDs) in the estimation of diffusion kurtosis model parameters. Results were obtained for a range of signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs), and for both the conventional case of Gaussian noise distribution and noncentral χ-distribution with different numbers of coils, m.
At low-to-moderate SNR, the noncentral χ-distribution deviates substantially from the Gaussian distribution. Our results indicate that this departure is more pronounced for larger values of m. As expected, the minimum SDs (i.e., CRLB) in derived diffusion kurtosis model parameters assuming a noncentral χ-distribution provided a closer match to the MC simulations as compared to the Gaussian results.
Estimates of minimum variance for parameter estimation and experimental design provided by the CRLB must account for the noncentral χ-distribution of noise in multi-coil acquisitions, especially in the low-to-moderate SNR regime. Magn Reson Med 79:3249-3255, 2018. © 2017 International Society for Magnetic Resonance in Medicine.
在磁共振(MR)实验的参数估计设计中,广泛使用克拉美-罗下限(CRLB)。在此计算中,之前的工作仅考虑了高斯或瑞利噪声分布。然而,在许多情况下,多线圈采集(如并行成像)的噪声分布服从非中心 χ 分布。本文的目的是提出用于多线圈采集的参数估计的 CRLB 计算。
我们对遵循非中心 χ 分布的噪声分布执行 Fisher 矩阵元素和相关 CRLB 的显式计算。扩散峰度的特殊情况作为一个重要的例子进行了检验。为了与分析结果进行比较,进行了蒙特卡罗(MC)模拟以评估扩散峰度模型参数估计的实验最小标准偏差(SD)。针对一系列信噪比(SNR)获得了结果,并且针对高斯噪声分布的常规情况和具有不同线圈数 m 的非中心 χ 分布都进行了研究。
在低到中等 SNR 下,非中心 χ 分布与高斯分布有很大的偏差。我们的结果表明,这种偏差对于较大的 m 值更为明显。正如预期的那样,假设非中心 χ 分布的扩散峰度模型参数的最小 SD(即 CRLB)与 MC 模拟的匹配度更高,而与高斯结果相比则较差。
参数估计和实验设计的最小方差估计值由 CRLB 提供,必须考虑多线圈采集的噪声的非中心 χ 分布,尤其是在低到中等 SNR 范围内。磁共振医学 79:3249-3255,2018。©2017 国际磁共振学会。