Prendergast Geoffrey P, Staff Michael
Northern Sydney Public Health Unit, Hornsby, NSW, Australia.
Noise Health. 2017 Mar-Apr;19(87):51-57. doi: 10.4103/nah.NAH_101_16.
This study examines the use of the number of night-time sleep disturbances as a health-based metric to assess the cost effectiveness of rail noise mitigation strategies for situations, wherein high-intensity noises dominate such as freight train pass-bys and wheel squeal.
Twenty residential properties adjacent to the existing and proposed rail tracks in a noise catchment area of the Epping to Thornleigh Third Track project were used as a case study. Awakening probabilities were calculated for individual's awakening 1, 3 and 5 times a night when subjected to 10 independent freight train pass-by noise events using internal maximum sound pressure levels (LAFmax).
Awakenings were predicted using a random intercept multivariate logistic regression model. With source mitigation in place, the majority of the residents were still predicted to be awoken at least once per night (median 88.0%), although substantial reductions in the median probabilities of awakening three and five times per night from 50.9 to 29.4% and 9.2 to 2.7%, respectively, were predicted. This resulted in a cost-effective estimate of 7.6-8.8 less people being awoken at least three times per night per A$1 million spent on noise barriers.
The study demonstrates that an easily understood metric can be readily used to assist making decisions related to noise mitigation for large-scale transport projects.
本研究考察了将夜间睡眠干扰次数作为一种基于健康的指标,以评估在高强度噪音(如货运列车驶过和车轮尖叫)占主导的情况下,铁路噪音缓解策略的成本效益。
以伊平至桑利第三轨道项目噪音集水区内现有和拟建铁轨附近的20处住宅物业为案例研究。利用内部最大声压级(LAFmax),计算个体在遭受10次独立的货运列车驶过噪音事件时,每晚醒来1次、3次和5次的觉醒概率。
使用随机截距多元逻辑回归模型预测觉醒情况。尽管预计每晚醒来三次和五次的中位数概率分别从50.9%大幅降至29.4%,以及从9.2%降至2.7%,但在采取源头缓解措施后,大多数居民预计每晚仍至少会被吵醒一次(中位数为88.0%)。这使得每花费100万澳元用于隔音屏障,每晚至少被吵醒三次的人数估计可减少7.6至8.8人,具有成本效益。
该研究表明,一个易于理解的指标可随时用于协助做出与大型交通项目噪音缓解相关的决策。