Saluja Saurabh, Silverstein Allison, Mukhopadhyay Swagoto, Lin Yihan, Raykar Nakul, Keshavjee Salmaan, Samad Lubna, Meara John G
Department of Surgery, Weill Cornell Medicine, New York, USA.
Department of Global Health and Social Medicine, Program in Global Surgery and Social Change, Harvard Medical School, Boston, USA.
BMJ Glob Health. 2017 Jul 13;2(2):e000269. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2016-000269. eCollection 2017.
The Lancet Commission on Global Surgery defined six surgical indicators and a framework for a national surgical plan that aimed to incorporate surgical care as a part of global public health. Multiple countries have since begun national surgical planning; each faces unique challenges in doing so. Implementation science can be used to more systematically explain this heterogeneous process, guide implementation efforts and ultimately evaluate progress. We describe our intervention using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research. This framework requires identifying characteristics of the intervention, the individuals involved, the inner and outer setting of the intervention, and finally describing implementation processes. By hosting a consultative symposium with clinicians and policy makers from around the world, we are able to specify key aspects of each element of this framework. We define our intervention as the incorporation of surgical care into public health planning, identify local champions as the key individuals involved, and describe elements of the inner and outer settings. Ultimately we describe top-down and bottom-up models that are distinct implementation processes. With the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research, we are able to identify specific strategic models that can be used by implementers in various settings. While the integration of surgical care into public health throughout the world may seem like an insurmountable challenge, this work adds to a growing effort that seeks to find a way forward.
《柳叶刀》全球外科委员会确定了六项外科指标以及一项国家外科计划框架,该框架旨在将外科护理纳入全球公共卫生的一部分。自那以后,多个国家已开始制定国家外科计划;每个国家在这样做的过程中都面临着独特的挑战。实施科学可用于更系统地解释这一异质性过程、指导实施工作并最终评估进展情况。我们使用实施研究综合框架来描述我们的干预措施。该框架要求确定干预措施的特征、所涉及的个人、干预措施的内部和外部环境,最后描述实施过程。通过举办一次有来自世界各地的临床医生和政策制定者参加的协商研讨会,我们能够明确该框架各要素的关键方面。我们将我们的干预措施定义为将外科护理纳入公共卫生规划,将当地倡导者确定为所涉及的关键个人,并描述内部和外部环境的要素。最终,我们描述了自上而下和自下而上这两种截然不同的实施过程模型。借助实施研究综合框架,我们能够确定实施者在各种环境中可以使用的具体战略模型。虽然将外科护理纳入全球公共卫生似乎是一项难以克服的挑战,但这项工作为寻求前进道路的不断增加的努力增添了力量。